Nvidia Shield K1 vs Google Nexus 9

stuman74

Well-known member
Nov 26, 2014
45
0
0
Well, I got my Nvidia Shield K1 last night from Best Buy. Pretty nice! Haven't fully put it through the paces yet, but thought I'd post some initial impressions and how it compares to my Google Nexus 9. I'm more of an Apple guy, but like the Android tablets due to the fact that I am a Clash of Clans addict and it's much easier to manage multiple accounts on Android OS. Anyway...

Form factor is very good. 16:9 screen as opposed to the N9 16:12. My use is in landscape view so being a little less wide is easier for gaming. It is also lighter, but of course the trade-off is the screen being only proportionally 75% the height of the N9. Also, holding the K1 is really nice with the "knurled" rubber speaker area on each end. Very nice to grip! The micro-usb power jack at the top takes some getting used to though.

Battery isn't all that great, but probably slightly better than the N9. Battery Saver mode on both stretched it out considerably. I've done timed battery tests while playing Clash and both at ~25-30% brightness. Below are how they compare.

Normal battery settings:
N9: 4:13 pace
K1: 4:30 pace

With Battery Saver on:
N9: 6:47 pace
K1: 7:30 pace​

Speed is very good. Buttery smooth in game play and other operations. Only a little slow at the very beginning setting up the tablet due to all the app downloads and updates which is not unexpected. Testing with the battery saver mode on for both tablets, the K1 seems faster. I ran Geekbench 3 on both in normal and battery saver modes.

Normal battery settings:
N9: 1983/3351
K1: 1130/3623

With Battery Saver on:
N9: 999/1693
K1: 741/1308​

Per these scores, it would seem the N9 is overall better, but maybe there are other factors like the screen size/pixels or graphics optimizations that have the K1 feeling a bit faster, especially in Battery Saver mode. Both are very fast though.

Sound seemed very good on the K1. However, I don't think there is any vibration or haptic feedback on the K1. I like that when typing on the screen, but of course not a deal breaker. I have not connected the K1 to a TV or anything yet. I also did not buy the gaming controller.

Price-wise, I had bought the N9 used for $200 on ebay a couple months ago and this K1 was new for $200. After playing around, the K1 will go back to the store or I'll sell the N9 (or give it to my kids). We'll see.

I'll post more observations and comparisons as I use the K1 more.
 
Good comparison. I expect the battery to get a little better after some days of use and after its had a chance to fully sync and download the apps and services you are using.
 
I'm very happy with mine as far as performance and sound go. Big complaints are power button squishyness and USB placement. Battery is great in standby but drops fast when playing games. However, in amazed at how long I can play COC in battery saved mode.

Posted via the Android Central App
 
Thanks. Yeah, hopefully the battery will get better after all the updates (though I think that's done) and maybe a full cycle or something. For the K1, the battery life measured at normal settings (54%/146min) was not starting at 100%, but the test in Battery Saver mode was (6%/29min). I'll probably get some more Clash time in tonight to measure :)

I noticed those "squishy" buttons as well. I like the N9 better in that regard. Also, while I did not yet test the K1 in a case, I would say that during game play (both normal and battery saver) it seems to feel not nearly as hot in my hands as the N9. I did notice the K1 warming up a bit during my initial setup and app updates.

One thing I am also a little concerned with, as time goes on, is the back cover seems to have a little bit of creak and flex at the edge seams. More annoying if anything, but wish a bit more solid like the N9 (or an iPad for that matter).

I just ordered this $11 case on Amazon which should arrive on Saturday:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0...ag=hawk-future-20&ascsubtag=UUacUvbUpU4949295
 
Last edited:
Here's some more benchmarks I ran to compare the K1 to the N9:

3D Mark - Sling Shot
1005: Nvidia Shield K1 (battery saver on)
1180: Nexus 9 16gb (battery saver on)
1670: Nexus 9 16gb
2481: Nvidia Shield K1

AnTuTu
51171: Nvidia Shield K1 (battery saver on)
63023: Nexus 9 16gb (battery saver on)
88440: Nvidia Shield K1
100148: Nexus 9 16gb

Quadrant Standard Edition
6920: Nexus 9 16gb (battery saver on)
7210: Nvidia Shield K1 (battery saver on)
14285: Nexus 9 16gb
16057: Nvidia Shield K1
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
954,232
Messages
6,960,994
Members
3,162,953
Latest member
vwssimalino