I had a watch 3 with a damaged bezel. I traded it in for the watch 4 classic. I got full trade in value. The questions askif the screen is cracked (not scratched) and if it powers up to the home screen and is reset. It worked fine if you didn't want to use the bezel. If you trade it in and they say something about the scratch, call them and complain. They tried to deny mine even though their pictures in the denial showed everything met the criteria. I got the whole amount with a 5 minute appeal call. Try it. What do you have to lose?