So... he praised the screen and ICS's UI. He then bashed the volume rocker placement, size, amount of configuration required, build quality, perceived speed, battery drain and lack of flash. M'kay.
The screen and UI are to be praised. On that, most will agree. As to the negatives:
* The placement of the volume rocker and phone size - I'm sure that most will adjust how they hold the phone. Kills two birds...
* Amount of config required - Google's features are vast. Fortunately, this is done only once or twice...
* Build quality - Cheaper manufacturing means more affordable price. If the phone is in a case and screen protector, does this really matter?
* On perceived speed, battery drain, and lack of Flash - the OS is NEW! As it's optimized, things should get slightly faster, the battery should drain less, and Flash will be available. One more thing for the battery- is anyone really surprised on the battery drain? There's a BIG screen and multi-processing... and a thin form-factor. I'm not surprised by the short battery life.
I wonder how people would react to having the option of tripling the thickness of the phone to triple the battery life... would they buy it? I'd bet that no one would buy it.
At the end, I'm not surprised by this review. The volume rocker location is good insight, but really, is a new phone really going to surprise anyone anymore???