Alright, I've given Gingerbread a good deal of shakedown. I started with the .588 non-root leak that came out a while ago, then sbf'd back to Froyo to put the official release on it.
First, the good:
I like the look of it. The dark colors look nice.
The updated blur is good too. Very clean. I have no problem with it. I know some people don't like Blur in general, but I like the latest version.
The bad:
- The camera is hit or miss. I don't mean in picture quality (although I've never been impressed). I mean in actually working. Hitting the camera button may or may not open the app. When it does open, it may or may not take a picture. If it does take a picture, it may or may not save that picture.
- The picture gallery may or may not work. Seriously, this was a problem before Gingerbread, yet it still exists. Do they even bother trying to fix it? Again, it's 50/50 on whether I'll be able to access my photos and pictures, or if I'm going to have to close the gallery app and reopen it and hope I'll be able to access my pictures.
- Messaging now sucks. SMS works fine. MMS is another hit or miss proposition. In fact, it's more miss than hit. I may be able to send a picture 1 out of 3 times. Receiving pictures is worse. Most of the time, my phone will not retrieve the pictures. Sometimes the MMS problem can be fixed by rebooting my phone, but often, it doesn't do anything.
- Sometimes data just flat out doesn't work. I can make calls, I can send SMS, but everything else that requires data just stops working randomly. This problem is fixed by restarting my phone, but it's become almost a daily occurrence. For some reason it just randomly stops dealing with data.
- Mail sync is no longer anywhere near as instantaneous as it was. On Froyo, my Gmail stuff would be pushed to the phone nearly instantly. Now, it's anywhere from 5 minutes to an hour. I've looked at all of my settings and it should be instant.
- Random reboots.
- Speaker volume is really, really low now. When I'm in a call, I can barely hear anybody. It's ridiculous. If I'm not in a dead quiet room, I'll miss most of what people are saying because I can't hear them. The volume on the phone is set at the maximum level, yet it's not even close to where it used to be.
- Still no way to access my Picasa albums in the Gallery. I know this isn't specifically a Gingerbread thing, but it's annoying to still not have this. My OG Droid tied it right into gallery, making it actually functional before they screwed that up with the Froyo update.
Things I've done to try and fix these problems:
- SBF to Froyo, reinstall GB (official install, 1st attempt)
- Factory reset, wipe cache (official install, 2nd attempt)
- Factory reset, wipe cache, wipe SD card (official install, 3rd attempt)
- SBF back to Froyo (again), factory reset, wipe cache, install GB, wipe cache, wipe SD card (official install, 4th attempt)
I'm done screwing with it. I've contemplated going back to Froyo permanently, but it will only be a temporary fix, and quite honestly I'm just completely annoyed with the whole damn thing. GB has been a bust for me. It's nothing but problem after problem after problem. It's not enough to make the phone unusable, but there are now important features that just don't work properly. Congrats, Gingerbread. You've succeeded in making me hate my phone.