Page 1 of 5 1234 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 25 of 120
Like Tree18Likes
  1. Thread Author  Thread Author    #1  

    Default Thoughts on the pentile screen?

    I'm having a harder time being excited for the s3 knowing it has pentile. Anyone have thoughts about this? I didn't like it on the razr. Kinda hurt my eyes.
  2. #2  

    Default Re: Thoughts on the pentile screen?

    While IPS does look better, I have found it to be more defective. I've gone through many iphone 4S's because of the horrible light bleeding.

    Never had an issue like that on any Samsung AMOLED display.
  3. #3  
    nkd
    nkd is offline
    nkd's Avatar

    Posts
    611 Posts
    Global Posts
    608 Global Posts

    Default Re: Thoughts on the pentile screen?

    Pentile has been given a bad name. I had the galaxy nexus for a bit and pentile on that looks 100 times better than razr maxx my friend has.

    I am not too worried about it. However galaxy nexus did look bad on low brightness when there was white background. From what I have read in reviews, samsung has tweaked the colors and screen and that issue is no longer there.
    Thanked by 2:
    BostonBeats88 likes this.
  4. #4  
    s14tat's Avatar

    Posts
    434 Posts
    ROM
    AOKP ICS build 38

    Default Re: Thoughts on the pentile screen?

    It's amazing how bad of a rep the pentile display gets now because of the crap that Motorola offered. When Samsung first had the original Galaxy S everyone was raving about how great that screen was. That is right, the screen on the original Galaxy S is also a pentile display. I occasionally see members here who rants about how they aren't happy that the Galaxy S 3 has a pentile display and thought it might look bad when they said that hey had owned a original Epic 4G ( sprint's version of the original Galaxy S ). So obviously they could not see the pentile effect on that low resolution screen. What makes them think they can see the pentile effect on such a high resolution screen?
    Spaniard85 likes this.
  5. #5  

    Default Re: Thoughts on the pentile screen?

    While the HTC One X screen, for example, looks incredible.. I really don't mind having the S3 with 'pentile'. First of all, it's at 720p HD resolution with a 306ppi screen. Lastly, the Galaxy S1 (Epic 4G, in my case) still looks great and that had a pentile screen.

    Of course, I would've liked Super AMOLED Plus.. but that's a given for everyone.
  6. #6  

    Default Re: Thoughts on the pentile screen?

    The Society for Information Display, world's experts on displays quality, have awarded the 2012 Display Application gold award to the Galaxy Note, a 5.3-inch PenTile OLED. This is the second year in a row that a PenTile OLED display has taken this coveted gold award. Perhaps PenTile displays are not so bad as some like to claim.
    Thanked by 3:
    deltascrew, Latino293 and Premium1 like this.
  7. #7  

    Default Re: Thoughts on the pentile screen?

    I love my Galaxy Note screen! I believe it has a ppi of 285 and it is great! I know some say they can see the sub pixel arrangement and I have no reason to doubt them, but I think the display is stunning as it is to most people that see it. I certainly cannot see anything which detracts from pictures, text or video. I have excellent vision.

    Can't wait to try out the SGSIII! I realize the HOX has a great screen, also but I am a Sammy fanboy and will stick with Samsung.
    Thanked by 3:
    21plays likes this.
  8. #8  

    Default

    What's even more wild....it's not even that bad on my RAZR. I had a g nex and have a Rezound.

    Pentile in general gets a bad rep.

    It's not getting a bad rep because of moto..it's getting a bad rap because some folks go by the pics zoomed in 100x...or hold the phone closer than normal looking for it. It got a bad rep when the HTC incredible and gs1 launched. That's well before moto used it.

    I think the g nex screen looks better....but I don't think it looks waaaay better. And compared to the Rezound...a non pentile screen? Prefer my RAZR screen alot more. Pentile doesn't take away from the RAZR screen at my normal distance, but the cons of the Rezound screen does.

    Sent from my DROID RAZR using Android Central Forums
    Last edited by jroc; 06-12-2012 at 04:58 PM.
  9. #9  
    Dreamliner330's Avatar

    Posts
    1,015 Posts
    Global Posts
    1,021 Global Posts
    ROM
    100% AOSP/AOKP wanted.

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by s14tat View Post
    It's amazing how bad of a rep the pentile display gets now because of the crap that Motorola offered. When Samsung first had the original Galaxy S everyone was raving about how great that screen was. That is right, the screen on the original Galaxy S is also a pentile display. I occasionally see members here who rants about how they aren't happy that the Galaxy S 3 has a pentile display and thought it might look bad when they said that hey had owned a original Epic 4G ( sprint's version of the original Galaxy S ). So obviously they could not see the pentile effect on that low resolution screen. What makes them think they can see the pentile effect on such a high resolution screen?
    Galaxy S screen sucked. I hope the S3 is better, but subpixel sharing is stupid. I won't hold my breath.
  10. #10  
    0pusX's Avatar

    Posts
    601 Posts
    Global Posts
    1,460 Global Posts
    ROM
    Stock

    Default Re: Thoughts on the pentile screen?

    I had a Galaxy Nexus a Razr and they are not even close in te same quality. I would even go as far as to say the Nexus is close to the iPhone 4S screen.

    The Razr on the other hand...... Ugh. Really bad screens as far as Razr and Maxx go
    Premium1 likes this.
  11. #11  

    Default Re: Thoughts on the pentile screen?

    I still think the display on my original Epic looks great. I was actually not very excited by the One X's display, it was smooth and great looking, but not as vibrant and over saturated, which I have always liked.
    With a higher resolution, the SIII will probably look great to any normal person.

    Of course I have mild astigmatism and don't often wear my glasses, it really smooths out those jagged edges.
    rudy847 likes this.
  12. #12  

    Default Re: Thoughts on the pentile screen?

    I have had the Bionic since September, and according to every forum and blog site it has the worst screen in the history of screens. It has a Pentile screen and for the first week or so it bothered me but after that I started to love it. Its great outdoors, gets better battery life, and its very bright (even at dimmer settings). As someone who has looked at a Pentile screen every single day since early September, I can say that it is a non issue. If you like everything else about the phone then get it, you won't be disappointed.
  13. #13  

    Default Re: Thoughts on the pentile screen?

    Motorola destroyed pentile screens. Much like they destroy everything they touch. This one will be fine, and won't matter at 1024x768.
    Premium1 likes this.
  14. #14  

    Default Re: Thoughts on the pentile screen?

    Quote Originally Posted by sk102704 View Post
    I have had the Bionic since September, and according to every forum and blog site it has the worst screen in the history of screens. It has a Pentile screen and for the first week or so it bothered me but after that I started to love it. Its great outdoors, gets better battery life, and its very bright (even at dimmer settings). As someone who has looked at a Pentile screen every single day since early September, I can say that it is a non issue. If you like everything else about the phone then get it, you won't be disappointed.
    Interesting, I had the opposite experience: I had the Moto Photon (similar screen to the Bionic), which at first I thought looked great, but over time I really noticed all those pixels, and it really started to bother me.

    I think the key is you really need to try any phone out intensely for the first few days to make sure you're ok with the display -- it seems opinions of what looks good to one person can vary wildly from that of another person.
  15. #15  

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by fredknex View Post

    Of course I have mild astigmatism and don't often wear my glasses, it really smooths out those jagged edges.
    Lol, man.

    Sent from my HTC One X using Android Central Forums
  16. #16  

    Default Re: Thoughts on the pentile screen?

    I currently have a Droid 3 and the pentile screen didn't really bother me at first, but as time wore on it started to bug me more and more. Especially in games and some videos. I'll be glad to get rid of it.

    I actually just went to a VZW store over lunch today to check out the Galaxy Nexus, specifically the size, but also the screen. I also checked out the Razer Maxx, which I was not too keen on. Although the Razr screen looked better than my Droid 3, it still shared the same issues for me. Happily, the screen of the GN looked fine to me.

    Bring on the GSIII!

    -Suntan
    Premium1 likes this.
  17. #17  

    Default Re: Thoughts on the pentile screen?

    razr is qhd not 720p. I have had the nexus and a maxx and could not see any pixels on the nexus so unless you do super up close shots of the phone you won't notice it. People blow it way out of proportion.
  18. #18  
    Dreamliner330's Avatar

    Posts
    1,015 Posts
    Global Posts
    1,021 Global Posts
    ROM
    100% AOSP/AOKP wanted.

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Premium1 View Post
    razr is qhd not 720p. I have had the nexus and a maxx and could not see any pixels on the nexus so unless you do super up close shots of the phone you won't notice it. People blow it way out of proportion.
    Same thing was said about qHD. It DOES matter.
  19. #19  

    Default Re: Thoughts on the pentile screen?

    For all you overly intelligent screen geeks out there; can you explain how Moto destroyed the screen on the Razr when they did not produce the screen? I thought it was purchased from anther company (Samsung?). If so, how and why did Moto make it worse?
    Just curious and not looking to debate since I don't know the answer. Just asking. So if you want to flame me on the net go right ahead. (But never in person!)

    Would really like to learn something of intelligence on this subject.
    C3H6N6O6 + (CH2)8(COOC8H17)2 + C4H8 + C5H8 = BOOM
    You don't shoot to kill; you shoot to stay alive!
    Thanked by:
    jroc 
  20. #20  

    Default Re: Thoughts on the pentile screen?

    Quote Originally Posted by dreamliner View Post
    Same thing was said about qHD. It DOES matter.
    Now, now, no need to start capitalizing...

    The truth is that we won't know for ourselves until they show up state-side. Right now the GN is the closest phone to check out. Or wait until next week or so and head to an AT&T store.

    -Suntan
  21. #21  

    Default Re: Thoughts on the pentile screen?

    Quote Originally Posted by RETG View Post
    For all you overly intelligent screen geeks out there; can you explain how Moto destroyed the screen on the Razr when they did not produce the screen? I thought it was purchased from anther company (Samsung?). If so, how and why did Moto make it worse?
    Just curious and not looking to debate since I don't know the answer. Just asking. So if you want to flame me on the net go right ahead. (But never in person!)

    Would really like to learn something of intelligence on this subject.
    Can't talk about the razr, but on my Droid 3 the "extra" pixel is white instead of green. This is great for use outdoors and really nice for reading black text on a white background, but at low light levels and certain colors, it looks kinda mucked up. That's my personal opinion based on using the Droid 3 for over a year.

    Also, I just think the colors and dithering on the Droid 3 screen is kinda poor. Although I don't really think this has to do with it being pentile.

    Based on playing with the Razr for about 4 minutes, it looked like a lot of the same as my Droid 3.

    -Suntan
  22. #22  

    Default Re: Thoughts on the pentile screen?

    Quote Originally Posted by happyturkey View Post
    Interesting, I had the opposite experience: I had the Moto Photon (similar screen to the Bionic), which at first I thought looked great, but over time I really noticed all those pixels, and it really started to bother me.

    I think the key is you really need to try any phone out intensely for the first few days to make sure you're ok with the display -- it seems opinions of what looks good to one person can vary wildly from that of another person.
    Photon , Bionic, and Matrix 2 all use the same display. Anyway, I've had a Bionic for a while, and sometimes the "screen door effect" (and lack of a decent yellow) is annoying, but after a while you don't notice it, and it is by far the best screen for outdoor use that I've ever seen. Having seen a Galaxy Nexus up close, the S3 should be nothing short of amazing. No reason to even consider talking bad about a screen that you've never seen before.
  23. #23  

    Default

    You know, I just dont get it why people complain so much about the Galaxy S3's display. Yes it may be Pentile but still its a really good high resolution display. Now it might not be as good as the HTC One X's Super LCD display but Super AMOLED produces very sharp contrast between colors, deep blacks and its also more power efficient than an LCD based display since it needs no back light to luminate the screen. Here is a comparison of all three generations of the Galaxy S and the G Nex.

    Okay so first there is the Galaxy S, it had a Pentile Super AMOLED display, the resolution of the screen was lower so it visually didnt look so good at times. Next there is the Galaxy S II, biger screen size and it was Super AMOLED Plus which uses an RGB matrix. Next there is the Galaxy Nexus, larger screen Super AMOLED HD with a Pentile sub pixel arangement like the Galaxy S3 that comes after it. As a comparison to the Pentile based Galaxy S it looks so much better. Samsung did do its homework here and the reason the SGS3 has a Pentile display is because Pentile displays do have longer longevity than RGB displays. The blue subpixels tend to deteriate the fastest so its better in a sense with Pentile displays because the subpixels are shared.

    In my personal opinion, the SGS3's display doesn't bother me the least bit because when I look for a phone, apperance isnt really a big deal. Its all about the features and I think the Galaxy S3 has some amazing features. Long story short, if you don't like the phone, then go buy you an HTC One X or some other device.

    Sent from my SPH-D710 using Android Central Forums
    Attached Thumbnails Attached Thumbnails Thoughts on the pentile screen?-uploadfromtaptalk1339554266012.jpg   Thoughts on the pentile screen?-uploadfromtaptalk1339554389096.jpg   Thoughts on the pentile screen?-uploadfromtaptalk1339554407786.jpg   Thoughts on the pentile screen?-uploadfromtaptalk1339554420124.jpg  
    Thanked by 2:
    21plays and jcp007 like this.
  24. #24  
    Dreamliner330's Avatar

    Posts
    1,015 Posts
    Global Posts
    1,021 Global Posts
    ROM
    100% AOSP/AOKP wanted.

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by coinmanmat View Post
    You know, I just dont get it why people complain so much about the Galaxy S3's display. Yes it may be Pentile but still its a really good high resolution display. Now it might not be as good as the HTC One X's Super LCD display
    Sounds like you know exactly why people complain.
  25. #25  

    Default Re: Thoughts on the pentile screen?

    Quote Originally Posted by coinmanmat View Post
    You know, I just dont get it why people complain so much about the Galaxy S3's display. Yes it may be Pentile but still its a really good high resolution display. Now it might not be as good as the HTC One X's Super LCD display
    Quote Originally Posted by dreamliner View Post
    Sounds like you know exactly why people complain.
    But... lets not forget this one lil nugget:

    Quote Originally Posted by happyturkey View Post

    I think the key is you really need to try any phone out intensely for the first few days to make sure you're ok with the display -- it seems opinions of what looks good to one person can vary wildly from that of another person.
    The screens for the most part will be a matter of opinion. No matter what the specs say, what reviewers say, what we say. Our own eyes will tell us this when we see the phones in person, side by side. As you can see...I'm probably the only one in this thread who likes the RAZR screen. I pick it up...compare it to my Rezound...that I dont even use that much anymore...and just shrug my shoulders...
Page 1 of 5 1234 ... LastLast

Posting Permissions

B