...build an S5, what would you put into it? (Cherry picking allowed)
-Reduce Screen size to about 4.8
-Use onscreen softkeys, like the Nexus
-Borrow the Moto X Processor
-Remove TW
-Remove the SD card
-Keep the removable battery, but borrow Moto's.
-Back plate be made of carbon fiber
-Similar speaker design of HTC One
-Reduce Screen size to about 4.8
Yeah, I'd be fine with this. I like the size of my S4, but I certainly don't want it to get any bigger...I have to carry this thing around with me!
-Use onscreen softkeys, like the Nexus
Definitely.
-Borrow the Moto X Processor
I'm not familiar enough with the Moto X hardware to comment...but none the less, I'm sure the processor will be upgraded.
-Remove TW
Not gonna happen. Would I put this on my own wishlist? I'm not sure...I do like vanilla Google Android in it's current state, but I don't really have any issues with the current TW either. I'm actually running a GE ROM on my S4 now, so obviously I probably lean that way, but at the same time if I felt that strongly about not having TW, the Galaxy S series is probably not the phone for me.
-Remove the SD card
Absolutely...but make 32GB the standard base model, and offer a 64GB as well...don't mess with 16GB at all. Offering 128GB would be even better. And don't charge me an extra $100 for each bump in storage.
-Keep the removable battery, but borrow Moto's.
Again, lack of experience with Moto's prevents a comment on this, but yeah, keep removable battery.
-Back plate be made of carbon fiber
I generally rock a case, so I'm usually not too concerned about this...but it doesn't sound like a bad idea.
-Similar speaker design of HTC One
Sure...why not!