[highfrequency]

For the love of progression please sign

[soondolee]

About time...

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Android Central Forums

[xhepera]

For the love of progression please sign

Done!

[2defmouze]

What you guys want is to see reform of the US Patent and courts systems... going after one judge is pointless, not to mention a waste of time as it's never going to happen.

[gabbott]

While I don't agree with the patent battles and what's been going on, does anyone really think this would accomplish anything to solve those issues other than focus some anger onto one judge?

[ultravisitor]

Oh good grief.

[arubamd]

Judge Lucy Koh should be impeached from her US district court position and promptly investigated for misuse of judicial powers and disbarred if necessary.

[gabbott]

Judge Lucy Koh should be impeached from her US district court position and promptly investigated for misuse of judicial powers and disbarred if necessary.

What misuse? Because we don't agree on a ruling for a phone we happen to like?

Don't get me wrong, I happen to think this whole patent thing is going too far, but then again so is this thread in what it's trying to do.

[KingGinger55]

Seriously? What is wrong wit you people? Ruining someones livelihood because they made a decision that you didn't like?

[ultravisitor]

What misuse? Because we don't agree on a ruling for a phone we happen to like?

Don't get me wrong, I happen to think this whole patent thing is going too far, but then again so is this thread in what it's trying to do.

Exactly. I don't like what's happening, but this thread and the petition just make people look like whiny babies.

[Paul627g]

My opinion I don't get involved in these situations. Sure our voice does make a difference in some respects and if we don't speak out how can we be heard but we also have to choose our battles wisely.

This ongoing war between Apple, Samsung and other OEMs over patten issues will continue to surge as Android gets stronger by the day. Apple has the money and resources to tie up in such battles, its up to the consumers at the end of the day to speak with their wallets as that will be the most effective resolution to this situation.

FWIW, lets keep this thread clean and free of problems..

Thanks everyone for your participation.

[asmallchild]

Gotta love Wikipedia

Personal

Koh is married to Stanford law professor . She is the first Asian American in the Northern District of California to take bribes from apple, the first District Court Judge of Korean descent in the United States, the first female Korean American Article III judge, and the second Korean American federal judge, after of the .

[ultravisitor]

If people wanted that to look real, then Apple would have been capitalized.

[ShinyTop]

If you have evidence of her bribe taking take it to the FBI. If she is enforcing laws on the books she is doing her job. Don't like the laws, get them changed through the avenues available. Yes, the patent laws are archaic and being misused. It is not the responsibility of the courts to change the laws, only enforce them.

[atlharry]

+1 to shiny top. Write your congressman instead and go sign the EFF petition for patent reform.

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2

[TabGuy]

Sadly this thread is reminiscent of a two year old stomping their feet and holding their breath because mommy won't give him candy.

We have a system in the U.S. folks. If you don't like the way it works then change the system, don't blame the enforcers.

Show some respect in how the process works and quit behaving like adolescents. Unless, of course, you are an adolescent.

[TerryMasters]

The petition says she's been "constantly granting Apple patent injunctions"... I'm assuming this means outside of the Galaxy Tab and Nexus, can anyone confirm and provide the information for what they were?

[g1toevo678]

So it's a righteous ruling if a judge rules against apple and one based on bribes and bias if not. I think this type of logic and behavior will actually hurt and turn some people off to android in the long run.

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2

[Speedygi]

Like many others have said, we can't do anything but accept this ruling. Doesn't mean we have no right to voice out about it though.

Sent from my HTC One X using Android Central Forums

[fed123]

This is nuttiness. If she is wrong on the law the appellate courts will correct her. Someone always loses in the lower court.

[Speedygi]

No, what Google should do now is counter sue, plain and simple. Shareholders should get on the phone now and ask why that isn't happening.

Sent from my HTC One X using Android Central Forums

[Shirke]

Apple has found a friend in the court. What her name?

[Mooem]

I respectfully disagree with this petition. Keep in mind this is the same judge who had initially denied an injunction early in the year (or was it December 2011?) for the tab but was forced to reconsider on appeal. She also denied giving Apple a hearing on the GSIII to give them an injunction. Well, that was more over Apple's choice as to not delay July's trial but regardless my point still stands.

We have appeals for this very reason. Let the process go through its paces, or work to change the system.

[pool_shark]

Lame!

[Iceman0803]

Judge Lucy Koh should be impeached from her US district court position and promptly investigated for misuse of judicial powers and disbarred if necessary.

I direct you to 2defmouze's post quoted below...specifically the bold part...

What you guys want is to see reform of the US Patent and courts systems... going after one judge is pointless, not to mention a waste of time as it's never going to happen.