Compass in the S20 Ultra not working

Mar 21, 2020
12
0
0
Visit site
Has anyone else noticed their compass not working on their S20 phones??

Mine just goes entirely unresponsive. So, for example, Google maps can no longer tell which direction I am facing.

Oddly enough, it starts working immediately after a phone restart. But then stops working again after a few minutes of phone idle time.
 
Mar 21, 2020
12
0
0
Visit site
Hi, welcome !

Is location on in maps settings?

Yup! I've been triple checking all location setting I possibly can. Maps, and all other Apps should have full Location permissions.

Its weird. The sensor clearly works perfectly immediately after a phone restart. But eventually just goes completely unresponsive. And there doesn't seem to be a set time for this to happen. I've monitored for up to an hour, and it keeps working. But eventually stops after this.
 
Mar 21, 2020
12
0
0
Visit site
Just to give you an idea of what's happening, I've attached an image of an App called "Accurate Compass". This app has a feature that allows you to check the status of your magnetometer. In this case, when the compass stops working, it just goes completely unresponsive, as if the phone can't even detect that a compass is present in the device at all.
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20200320-161118_Accurate Compass.jpg
    Screenshot_20200320-161118_Accurate Compass.jpg
    139.1 KB · Views: 11

mustang7757

Super Moderator
Moderator
Feb 6, 2017
89,228
3,254
113
Visit site
Yup! I've been triple checking all location setting I possibly can. Maps, and all other Apps should have full Location permissions.

Its weird. The sensor clearly works perfectly immediately after a phone restart. But eventually just goes completely unresponsive. And there doesn't seem to be a set time for this to happen. I've monitored for up to an hour, and it keeps working. But eventually stops after this.
They have a way in maps to do the calibration for compass but not sure it will fix your issue since it's good for a little and then acts up
 
Mar 21, 2020
12
0
0
Visit site

Thanks for the link!

Yeah I saw this issue in other S20s. I think this may actually be a separate issue. As my GPS is actually spot-on all the time (so farm anyway)! In fact, when I go to try and calibrate the compass (using that figure eight pattern), nothing happens. Just seems like the compass goes completely unresponsive. However when its working, no calibration is needed at all! Works perfectly
 
Mar 21, 2020
12
0
0
Visit site
Thanks for the feedback guys! I am trying to reply to your posts, but right now my quick replies are being sent to a moderator for approval first.

But just wanted to say thank you! I really appreciate the help.
 

Mike Dee

Ambassador
May 14, 2014
23,232
3
38
Visit site
Thanks for the feedback guys! I am trying to reply to your posts, but right now my quick replies are being sent to a moderator for approval first.

But just wanted to say thank you! I really appreciate the help.
When does it usually go bad? I tested mine a few times since your first post and can't replicate your issue.
 
Mar 21, 2020
12
0
0
Visit site
@Mike Dee It was always about 1-2 hours after phone restart, and the compass would go totally unresponsive. Since it worked exactly as intended up to this point, I assumed it was probably software based, and not hardware.

And actually, I am beginning to trace the problem. I decided to reboot my phone in Safe Mode (thank you Samsung support for NOT recommending I do this after talking to 4 agents), just to see if that affected the functionality.

I left the phone plugged in overnight, remaining in safe mode the entire time. And wouldn't you know, the compass is still working perfectly this morning! Much longer than it has gone before. SO this all is starting to suggest a software conflict with the compass. And specifically, a piece of software I must have loaded onto the phone. This would also kind of make sense based on what I was seeing, since the compass always works for a certain time after restart. An app must be loading up in the background sometime after restart that interferes with the comms of the compass??

Since the compass is still working nearly 12 Hrs later, I am going to assume its another app I am using that is interfering.
But now my issue is... how can I determine which app, short of uninstalling each one, one at a time!? (this is no small task, since I copied over ALL apps from my previous S8, so there are quite a few).

Question to the community: is there an app which can monitor the usage and background processed of other apps over time?

If I could closely watch when the compass stops working, and then trace the background activity of the phone at the same time, that should tell me which app is interfering.
 

Mike Dee

Ambassador
May 14, 2014
23,232
3
38
Visit site
@Mike Dee It was always about 1-2 hours after phone restart, and the compass would go totally unresponsive. Since it worked exactly as intended up to this point, I assumed it was probably software based, and not hardware.

And actually, I am beginning to trace the problem. I decided to reboot my phone in Safe Mode (thank you Samsung support for NOT recommending I do this after talking to 4 agents), just to see if that affected the functionality.

I left the phone plugged in overnight, remaining in safe mode the entire time. And wouldn't you know, the compass is still working perfectly this morning! Much longer than it has gone before. SO this all is starting to suggest a software conflict with the compass. And specifically, a piece of software I must have loaded onto the phone. This would also kind of make sense based on what I was seeing, since the compass always works for a certain time after restart. An app must be loading up in the background sometime after restart that interferes with the comms of the compass??

Since the compass is still working nearly 12 Hrs later, I am going to assume its another app I am using that is interfering.
But now my issue is... how can I determine which app, short of uninstalling each one, one at a time!? (this is no small task, since I copied over ALL apps from my previous S8, so there are quite a few).

Question to the community: is there an app which can monitor the usage and background processed of other apps over time?

If I could closely watch when the compass stops working, and then trace the background activity of the phone at the same time, that should tell me which app is interfering.
Hardware problems can be intermittent especially if it's heat related. I was going to suggest safe mode next. It's tough to pinpoint the actual app that might be causing the conflict though. Sometimes the only way is to start with a clean install and install a few apps at a time. It's probably one of the more obscure apps.
 
Mar 21, 2020
12
0
0
Visit site
SO! Another quick update. *knock on wood* I think I found the culprit...

Short of finding an app that tracks the activity of all Android apps and processes, I decided to start disabling things one by one. Checking after each "Force Stop" to see if the compass started working.

It is looking like it may have been caused by a live background app called "BETTA" (a cool animated Beta Fish for your Home Page). Turning off the live background immediately allowed the sensor to start working again. It has been working steadily since yesterday!

Not a CLUE as to why the live background would interfere with the compass. Probably the darn ads in the background. I am testing the same app on my Galaxy S8, but it doesn't seem to affect this phone. Something about the S20 and this app appears to interfere.

I don;t think its the live wallpaper function itself either. As I have another one loaded to test functionality, and all is working fine. Seems to be this app called "BETTA" specifically.

Hope it keeps working!! I will update accordingly with what I find if anything changes.
Many thanks to the input from everyone!
Cheers
-Chris
 

Mike Dee

Ambassador
May 14, 2014
23,232
3
38
Visit site
SO! Another quick update. *knock on wood* I think I found the culprit...

Short of finding an app that tracks the activity of all Android apps and processes, I decided to start disabling things one by one. Checking after each "Force Stop" to see if the compass started working.

It is looking like it may have been caused by a live background app called "BETTA" (a cool animated Beta Fish for your Home Page). Turning off the live background immediately allowed the sensor to start working again. It has been working steadily since yesterday!

Not a CLUE as to why the live background would interfere with the compass. Probably the darn ads in the background. I am testing the same app on my Galaxy S8, but it doesn't seem to affect this phone. Something about the S20 and this app appears to interfere.

I don;t think its the live wallpaper function itself either. As I have another one loaded to test functionality, and all is working fine. Seems to be this app called "BETTA" specifically.

Hope it keeps working!! I will update accordingly with what I find if anything changes.
Many thanks to the input from everyone!
Cheers
-Chris
Tested the app on my Note 10 and it caused issues. Compass read West pointing North
and sensor was disabled. I took the app off and after about 30 seconds everything went back to normalScreenshot_20200323-125159_Compass.jpeg
 

Mike Dee

Ambassador
May 14, 2014
23,232
3
38
Visit site
SO! Another quick update. *knock on wood* I think I found the culprit...

Short of finding an app that tracks the activity of all Android apps and processes, I decided to start disabling things one by one. Checking after each "Force Stop" to see if the compass started working.

It is looking like it may have been caused by a live background app called "BETTA" (a cool animated Beta Fish for your Home Page). Turning off the live background immediately allowed the sensor to start working again. It has been working steadily since yesterday!

Not a CLUE as to why the live background would interfere with the compass. Probably the darn ads in the background. I am testing the same app on my Galaxy S8, but it doesn't seem to affect this phone. Something about the S20 and this app appears to interfere.

I don;t think its the live wallpaper function itself either. As I have another one loaded to test functionality, and all is working fine. Seems to be this app called "BETTA" specifically.

Hope it keeps working!! I will update accordingly with what I find if anything changes.
Many thanks to the input from everyone!
Cheers
-Chris
I left a review with issues and also emailed developer
 
Mar 21, 2020
12
0
0
Visit site
I left a review with issues and also emailed developer


Mike Dee
Many thanks for double checking and validating that it was the app causing this issue!
Yep, I think this all but confirms there is a problem with this app. I will do the same, posting a review and emailing the developer. Hopefully they can look into it. What an odd one this was.

Thank you again! Hopefully this helps someone else if they run into the same issue.
Cheers
-Chris
 

Mike Dee

Ambassador
May 14, 2014
23,232
3
38
Visit site
Mike Dee
Many thanks for double checking and validating that it was the app causing this issue!
Yep, I think this all but confirms there is a problem with this app. I will do the same, posting a review and emailing the developer. Hopefully they can look into it. What an odd one this was.

Thank you again! Hopefully this helps someone else if they run into the same issue.
Cheers
-Chris
You're most welcome. The app did a nice job otherwise.
 

Trending Posts

Forum statistics

Threads
938,701
Messages
6,890,606
Members
3,156,336
Latest member
jocatz