I know this is an old thread, but I'm a new D2G owner and I feel like I've got to say something about the keyboard: I LOVE IT!!!
Honestly, I don't think VZW did a very good job promoting this phone. I went from a BB to the DX and missed a physical keyboard terribly, but all I'd ever heard about the Droid line was how crappy their keyboards were.
When I checked for myself, I admit I agreed. The keyboard on the original Droid and even the D2 felt like a big mat of plastic, with no key divisions or responsiveness.
I only started thinking of the D2G recently again, when I finally decided to give up waiting for the mythical HTC Merge. When I went to my VZW store to check it out, I was shocked to find the D2G has a completely different keyboard from the D2! The keys are totally detached from each other (like little individual square keys) and are totally clicky and responsive.
I don't think enough people know about this. Everyone in the Merge forums I frequented assumed all the Droids had that mat-style keyboard. Even my local VZW store had put the D2 out on display as the D2G, claiming they were identical. I got lucky that I happened to pick up the one actual D2G that they had out and noticed the difference. The guys that worked there were surprised--even they hadn't known that the D2G keyboard was different.
VZW should be talking up this keyboard WAY more, at least to their own employees!!