If you want a brand new device, you will be forced to use an upgrade, and pay the 2 year price. Otherwise, you are given certified like new options. The Maxx is too new and doesn't have certified like new replacements so don't count on getting that. Given the Bionic's issues, I'd take a Rezound if offered. If you purchased an extended battery, and ask nicely, a rep may also replace that at no charge. Be nice to the reps and they will work with you.