Incipio dual pro vs otterbox commuter

[johnnyshinta]

I have a defender but I find it to be a bit too cumbersome. I'm trying to decide between the incipio dual pro (possibly shine) and the otterbox commuter. Has anyone had experience with both that can give an opinion? I'm leaning towards the incipio because it's red and I have a red m8. It is also a tad less bulky than the commuter.