I replaced mine 3 weeks ago due to radio issues and got a 'certified' replacement original Droid. I had read rumors from a few months back that people were scoring D2's, but apparently Verizon has dug some up from somewhere.
I feared that I would get some sort of refurb that came back through the VZ tradein / buyback program but I got what looked to be a pretty brand new OG Droid. No nicks, no bumps or bruises and a flawless screen ...it really did look like a brand new phone right out of the box. Only difference is that Verizon makes you keep your battery and battery door, charger, etc.. and just send the phone back to them.
It will be nice to sell to Gazelle or via eBay's buyback program when I upgrade.
PS: The rep on the phone gave me the run around, or tried to and finally she told me to pick up the insurance for $2 and then send phone back... which is what I did and how I got the phone because mine was 'out of warranty'.