PenTile Display - First Impressions

When bringing up the PPI you have to account for the difference in screen sizes as well.

Agreed, also the Engadget review of the Note 3 said the display type was a thing of art and that the matrix display works and looks beautiful. And they arent typically afraid to trash phones so that should tell us something.
 
Let's put this puppy to bed concerning this post, let's go to the expert in the field of displays. The company's name is Display Mate, they test displays for a living. Let's see what they found in their testing of the Note 3 Display:

Image Sharpness and Pixels Per Inch
The Galaxy Note 3 has a pixel density of 388 Pixels Per Inch PPI, which is very high, but lower than the 441 PPI for the Galaxy S4 and other Full HD Smartphone displays. It?s important to recognize that this is not a decrease in visual image sharpness because the display still appears perfectly sharp for 20/20 Vision at typical viewing distances of 13 inches or more because the Pixels and Sub-Pixels are below normal visual acuity. (The Galaxy Note is 14 percent larger than the Galaxy S4 so it is typically held further away). The Galaxy Note 3 also has a PenTile Sub-Pixel arrangement like the Galaxy S4, with only 2 Sub-Pixels per Pixel instead of the usual 3. But at these very high PPIs, it?s not visually noticeable because of the use of Sub-Pixel Rendering and the Diamond Sub-Pixel arrangement discussed below. For more information on visual image sharpness see High PPI PenTile Displays and Visual Sharpness and Resolution.

Also their conclusion
Galaxy Note 3 Conclusions: An Impressive OLED Display?
The Galaxy Note 3 continues the rapid and impressive improvement in OLED displays and technology. The first notable OLED Smartphone, the Google Nexus One, came in decidedly last place in our 2010 Smartphone Display Shoot-Out. In a span of just a few years OLED display technology is now challenging and even exceeding the performance of the best LCDs across the board in brightness, contrast, color accuracy, color management, picture quality, screen uniformity, and viewing angles. OLEDs are also considerably thinner than LCDs but still cost considerably more to manufacture.

The Galaxy Note 3 has the newest generation of OLED display technology. The Lab tests show that it is better than the Note II in every measurement category, and also comparable or better than the display on the Galaxy S4. It has double the resolution of the Note II, which is a major improvement, but the most impressive advancement for the Note 3 is its significantly brighter screen, which hits an incredible 660 cd/m2 in high ambient light, the brightest mobile display we have ever tested in the Shoot-Out series. An impressive achievement for OLEDs!

OLEDs need to continue improving their power efficiency, which is critically important for mobile displays. We measured an impressive 26 percent improvement in power efficiency between the Galaxy Note 3 and Note II. While LCDs remain more power efficient for images with mostly white content (like text screens, for example), OLEDs are more efficient for darker content because they are emissive rather than transmissive like LCDs. In fact, Galaxy Note 3 is already 31 percent more power efficient than the Full HD LCD Smartphones we recently tested for mixed image content (that includes photos and videos, for example) with a 50 percent Average Picture Level, APL. If this keeps up then OLEDs may pull ahead of LCDs in total power efficiency in the near future?

What?s Next? The most important developments for the upcoming generations of both OLED and LCD mobile displays will come from improvements in their image and picture quality in ambient light, which washes out screen images, resulting in reduced readability, image contrast, and color saturation and accuracy. The key will be in dynamically changing the display?s color management and intensity scales in order to automatically compensate for reflected glare and image wash out from ambient light. See this article on display performance in ambient light. The displays and technologies that succeed in implementing this new strategy will take the lead in the next generations of mobile displays?


Samsung provided DisplayMate Technologies with a pre-release production unit to test and analyze for this Display Technology Shoot-Out article.

The Shoot-Out
To examine the performance of the Samsung Galaxy Note 3 we ran our in-depth series of Mobile Display Technology Shoot-Out Lab tests and included the Galaxy Note II in order to determine how OLED displays have improved. We take display quality very seriously and provide in-depth objective analysis side-by-side comparisons based on detailed laboratory measurements and extensive viewing tests with both test patterns and test images. To see how far mobile displays have progressed in just three years see our 2010 Smartphone Display Shoot-Out, and for a real history lesson see our original 2006 Smartphone Display Shoot-Out.

Results Highlights
In this Results section we provide Highlights of the comprehensive Lab measurements and extensive side-by-side visual comparisons using test photos, test images and test patterns that are presented below. The Comparison Table section summarizes the Lab measurements in the following categories: Screen Reflections, Brightness and Contrast, Colors and Intensities, Viewing Angles, OLED Spectra, Display Power. You can also skip the Highlights and go directly to the Conclusions.

The Galaxy Note 3 has the newest generation of Samsung OLED displays since the Galaxy S4 Smartphone, which launched in April. The Lab tests below show that it is better than the Note II in every measurement category, and also comparable or better than the Galaxy S4. It has double the resolution of the Note II, which is a major improvement, but the most important advancement for the Note 3 is its significantly brighter screen?

Impressive Brightness
Up until the Galaxy Note 3, OLED displays have been somewhat to significantly dimmer than competing LCD displays. The Note 3 has changed that in a big way?it?s an impressive 55 percent brighter than the Note II and a solid 25 percent brighter than the Galaxy S4. For most image content it provides over 400 cd/m2, comparable or higher than most LCD displays in this size class. Even more impressive is that when Automatic Brightness is turned on, the Note 3 hits an incredible 660 cd/m2 in high ambient light, where it?s needed (85 percent brighter than the Note II and 40 percent brighter than the Galaxy S4 with Automatic Brightness) ? the brightest mobile display we have ever tested in the Shoot-Out series. An impressive achievement for OLEDs!




If you want to read their whole article concerning the note 3 display

Galaxy Note 3 Display Technology Shoot-Out
 
Now that is what I call a thorough review of a screen. If anyone still complains "oh but its pentile" after reading that, well, better go get something that isn't.
 
When you're watching TV you're several feet away. I'm sure the display on the Note 3 is sharp but nobody is standing 10 feet away when they use a phone.
 
When you're watching TV you're several feet away. I'm sure the display on the Note 3 is sharp but nobody is standing 10 feet away when they use a phone.

......Your TV is also 50" + ........ your phone is not...... so 1920x1080 packed into 50" at 12 feet away makes sense and you see no pixels ... just as 1920 x 1080 packed into 6" from 13" away you see no pixels.
 
I never said you'd see pixels, just thought it didn't make sense that he compared it to a TV but I get it now. Haven't seen a pixel on my S4 and I have 20/20 vision :)
 
I checked out the Note 3 last night and compared it to my Note 2.

The display is considerably brighter and crisper but the colours look washed out compared with the Note 2. And I can see the pentile pixel effect if I try to look for it.

Also I compared the audio while playing the same video clip at maximum volume and it sounds extremely tinny and lacks any depth unlike my Note 2. I know the Note 2 speaker is nothing special but seriously the Note 3 speaker is an embarrassment.

The display being pentile and the audio quality is a deal breaker for me. :(

As the spec sheet is simply amazing and I prefer the new look I just wish Sammy would ship it with a non pentile display and a better speaker then I would probably be happy to get one. :D

I typed up a longer post before my Chrome browser updated it self on my Note 2 so I lost it lol :(. This is just a quick retype.
 
The pentile screen is the main reason I'm thinking of waiting to see if the HTC One Max comes out for Verizon.
 
Now owning the Note 3, I'll just say this: Professor Xavier is recruiting for you guys that can identify how bad Pentile looks on this phone. lol
 

Forum statistics

Threads
954,035
Messages
6,960,318
Members
3,162,903
Latest member
Zoran