Physical or Virtual keyboards

I initially started out with an iphone and that convinced me the I my next smart device would *have* to have a physical keyboard. I spent the last few months demo'ing every slider/physical keyboard phone I could get my hands on in search of that elusive "perfect" feeling physical keyboard. A few came close but most of them were just "off" in one way or another.

Then, along comes the Evo with its gigantic slab of a display that surely it would be worth a try and re-visiting my initial iphone-induced wariness of soft keyboards.

I couldnt have found a more perfect typing surface. One of the perfect things about Android soft keyboards is the availability of choices and ability to swap out different keyboards - something that is (obviously) completely absent with a physical keyboard or iphone and the thing that truly seals the deal, so to speak.

After using Swype and SwiftKey on the Evo, I have abosolutely been converted to soft keyboards - provided it's on an Android, or other system that allows the flexibility to change out things like the keyboard.

I prefer Swype in portrait mode and SwiftKey in landscape. I find that portrait mode works better for me typing one handed and is amazingly fast, fluid and accurate with Swype. Just zing my thumb around a little on the Swype keyboard area and somehow, amazingly, intelligible text emerges. In landscape, I find the physical size of th Evo is a detriment to Swype use however. Landscape on the Evo offers the roominess that just makes two-handed typing a dream and - since you have to cover so much real estate just makes Swype tedious and is where SwiftKey shines. Its auto correct and prediction scare me they are so good. I can, essentially, just mash my two thumbs in the general area of the keyboard and somehow it just seems to know what I intended to type. I really am kind of freaked out by it sometimes.

Its gotten to the point that I find myself almost beginning to use the habits I've developed on the Evo when I'm typing at my computer's keyboard and starting to feel frustrated with the "dubmness" of my main computer's full size physical keyboard. I'll be typing along and realize I've made some sort of typo and wonder how/why my computer let that slip and didn't go back and auto correct what I meant to type, insert grammatically correct punctuation and just "know" what I was trying to type in the first place like my Evo seems to. Funny as it is, I think I can churn out *accurate* text faster on my Evo than on a full size physical keyboard on a regular computer.

Smart phone sized flip/slide outs aren't even a consideration anymore and I find myself thinking of them more as a quaint throwback to outdated technology than something useful - kind of like a rotary dial telephone or something.
 
I prefer physical keyboard, but I've been using the HTC IME MOD, and its pretty cool. Adjusted the width and height 6 px each, and its great. Almost exactly like the iPhone keyboard.
 
coming from a htc touch, to a pre, then to evo i thought id miss the keys, but with a 4.3" screen i dont understand and it still boggles my mind how people say they cant type on the evo, a monkey could bang out 60 wpp on that thing, its such a ez learning curve and after a while i learned to like how i didnt need to slide a keyboard out or worry about hardware keys not working
 
How do you get swype? I cant find it in the Android market.

shoot me a msg if you want swype, i'll send it to ya.

and on topic, SWYPE FTW!! virtual keyboards on this huge screen work great for me. had a touch pro before, small device which makes virtual harder & thus the benefit of the hardware keyboard.
 
correct me if im wrong guys, but swype isnt on the evo, u can get it by hacking the evo and or if you had a beta sign up for it

hacking the evo? huh wot!?!?!

all it takes is to install the .apk file which is rather easy to do. might take all of 30 seconds

if ANYONE wants it, shoot me a message so you can check it out.
 
correct me if im wrong guys, but swype isnt on the evo, u can get it by hacking the evo and or if you had a beta sign up for it
That's not true. I'm using swype now thanks to a fellow poster. It works great. I didn't think that I would like it at first, but it makes one handed typing really easy and fun and I did not have to hack my phone. It does seem to have some trouble detecting the words in my custom dictionary. Also it doesn't do the double tap period. Other than that it is great!
 
I came from a Treo. All in all, I think I still prefer the Treo keyboard: I was just more accurate with it. BUT, after 5 or 6 weeks, I'm getting close to being as accurate (thanks in part to prediction), and maybe a bit faster than I was on the Treo. In landscape, that is. In portrait, I'm not very good at all.

But the Treo 755p and it's twins had the best keyboard I've found on any phone. Better than BB, and way better than the Pre. Compared to the cramped, midget keyboard on the Pre, the landscape keyboard on the Evo is definitely an improvement.

I agree that the Treo keyboards were awesome.

However, I don't do enough typing on the phone to justify the bulk of a keyboard. I prefer the sleekness of a candy-bar style phone.
 
For those of you coming from smartphone with physical keyboards or have had a lot of experience with physical keyboards, how has your experience with the virtual keyboard of the EVO? I have to say, I prefer the typing experience on my EVO. I think that the keyboard is even better than the iPhone keyboard. What do you guys think?

I was never a fan of virtual keyboards. I started my Smart Phone journey with Blackberry (Pearl 8130 > Curve 8330m > Tour 9630) then when I was ready for Android went to the Samsung Moment first. I got the EVO about 2 weeks ago and was a little worried about the virtual keyboard until I used it.

I downloaded Swype for my Moment since I'm in the closed beta and practiced with that. One of the first things I did was download Swype to my EVO when I got it from Best Buy. Now, I find myself using the EVO keyboard cause it seems smoother to me. I got the hang of it pretty quickly.
 
I was never a fan of virtual keyboards. I started my Smart Phone journey with Blackberry (Pearl 8130 > Curve 8330m > Tour 9630) then when I was ready for Android went to the Samsung Moment first. I got the EVO about 2 weeks ago and was a little worried about the virtual keyboard until I used it.

I downloaded Swype for my Moment since I'm in the closed beta and practiced with that. One of the first things I did was download Swype to my EVO when I got it from Best Buy. Now, I find myself using the EVO keyboard cause it seems smoother to me. I got the hang of it pretty quickly.
Swype is pretty slick. To be honest, I didn't think that I would like it, but I have already started to get used to it. I have been playing around with it for about two hours and it is a nice alternative to the stock keyboard. I still can't believe how accurate it is. All we need now is full flash support and we EVO users are good to go! Thanks again to the guy who sent me the application. You really made my day.
 
Swype is pretty slick. To be honest, I didn't think that I would like it, but I have already started to get used to it. I have been playing around with it for about two hours and it is a nice alternative to the stock keyboard. I still can't believe how accurate it is. All we need now is full flash support and we EVO users are good to go! Thanks again to the guy who sent me the application. You really made my day.

Swype is definitely quick, I agree with you on that. I just think for me personally I type faster on the stock keyboard. I think it's cause I'm so used to a physical keyboard my brain wants me to type the 'regular' way.....lol I'm definitely not going to give up on Swype though. :)
 
I was a bit wary of having to use a virtual keyboard at first, but I've found that I can type much faster on the evo than on the G1's physical keyboard. The large screen and the predicate text both help with making a faster testing experience.
 
Swype is definitely quick, I agree with you on that. I just think for me personally I type faster on the stock keyboard. I think it's cause I'm so used to a physical keyboard my brain wants me to type the 'regular' way.....lol I'm definitely not going to give up on Swype though. :)

Don't get me wrong, I type faster with my thumbs on the stock keyboard. But this is a nice alternative to one handed typing.
 
I really liked my Pre's physical keyboard. Even though it was small it worked very well.
Touchscreen boards never really worked for me too well. I even considered returning my EVO because there was no physical keyboard.

However I then downloaded Swype!

Typing is now fun and easy. I can do things on Swype that I never could on a real keyboard.

Summary: Stock touch screen is bad. Download a new keyboard.
 
Coming from a Blackberry 8330/8530, I prefer the touchscreen keyboard of Evo (especially with the Droid X KB installed.)

The BB keyboards felt slightly cramped to me, and I have small hands.
 
Coming from a Blackberry 8330/8530, I prefer the touchscreen keyboard of Evo (especially with the Droid X KB installed.)

The BB keyboards felt slightly cramped to me, and I have small hands.

I love the keyboard of the curve. It was one of my favorite keyboards of any smartphone I have had. But I still like swype better.
 
My wife before had the 8703e, Curve, Samsung Moment, she said she never use a touch screen until she played with evo ever since she got the evo she doesnt want to use any other phone loves the evo and the touchscreen, so it is just a pref and it will take some time to get use to touch screen.
 
Coming from the Pre and a loooong list of Treo devices, i prefer physical keyboards more because i type pretty fast and virtual keyboards don't always respond well to the speed. HTC's funky layout with the arrow keys make things even worse but Swype and Shapewriter makes the virtual keyboard experience much better... and thank God for spell check/correction!!!
 
Coming from the Pre and a loooong list of Treo devices, i prefer physical keyboards more because i type pretty fast and virtual keyboards don't always respond well to the speed. HTC's funky layout with the arrow keys make things even worse but Swype and Shapewriter makes the virtual keyboard experience much better... and thank God for spell check/correction!!!
After you get used to the virtual keyboard, I think that you will think differently, I type faster and more accurately on the virtual keyboard than I did on my blackberry. I used to think that the blackberry keyboard was the best, until now.
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
956,432
Messages
6,968,237
Members
3,163,542
Latest member
04ijordan