For those who had the Pixel 5 and returned because of small size, do you mean the feel in the hand is too small? I have a Pixel 3A XL that has a 6inch display and the Pixel 5 has a 6inch display as well. Is the screen pretty much the same thing or does it feel more cramped on the Pixel 5? Like the icons are closer together on the homescreen and app drawer?
I guess what I am trying to figure out is if I can just imagine the Pixel 5 being the same screen as my 3A XL with very small bezels around it. I can't imagine that feels small unless the screen is not the same and is more narrow and taller on the 5.
My mother has the 3aXL, and I have the Pixel 5 (coming from the Pixel 2xl and before that, the Nexus 6), and although the screens are the same size, the aspect ratios are different.
The Nexus 6 had a 16:9 aspect ratio.
The Pixel 2xl had an 18:9 aspect ratio.
The Pixel 3aXL has an 18.5:9 aspect ratio.
The Pixel 5 has a 19.5:9 aspect ratio.
Because of this, the Nexus 6 was the widest and biggest, while the Pixel 5 is the slimmest and the smallest. I have an Otterbox Defender Pro case on it and it feels just fine. It's nice to be able to get the benefits of a 6 inch screen with one-handed use. The screen does not look small at all. When I put it next to my mother's 3aXL, the screen sizes look basically the same.
On top of this, the Pixel 5 is almost without bezels, thus the screen takes up practically the entire phone (very good thing). It is visually appealing and satisfying. I'm sure the 4a5g will give a similar feel.