This old S8...Is it worth the trouble to root it and flash a custom ROM? Would I be able to get another Android version update or two?

Dark Penguin

Well-known member
Aug 21, 2011
414
2
18
Visit site
I've had an old s8 almost since the model came out, still my daily driver, and for the record, I have a spare one which I use potentially for anything that doesn't require a working SIM card. It'll become clear why I mentioned the spare S8, though you can probably guess from the thread title. The second S8 originally belonged to my wife, but she upgraded to an S9.

My daily driver S8 has been kept fully stock, so the KNOX bit hasn't been flipped. As I found when I bought it, there's really not much need to tinker with a flagship model because they have enough memory, storage, and processing muscle to perform well. In fact, mine still does very well considering all that I have crammed on to it, despite being almost seven years old. Everything still runs with the exception of one finance related app that says the new version cannot run on my phone. That's not a huge deal, I can still access my account on the browser. But if you have a seven-year-old device, when this happens, you can't help worrying that it's only the thin end of the wedge. What's the next thing that's going to stop working? What if it's something I use almost daily, like Google Maps GPS, and there is no viable browser-based workaround?

I pretty much stopped posting here when we got the S8s, because my main reason for being here was to talk about rooting and flashing custom ROMs, and I just didn't need to do that anymore. But now I'm wondering if it's time to reconsider. Long ago, probably around late 2015 or early '16, I accepted the Marshmallow update on my S5, which this step basically cut off at the knees. With the increased resource demands of Marshmallow compared to Lollipop, almost everything stopped working-- until I rooted it and flashed a custom ROM. After everything worked fine, and I had made my phone great again. (After flashing the custom ROM, though my memory isn't 100% clear, I also modified it to use part of the storage card as virtual internal memory, which also helped.)

My current phone is still great, but is it possible that I could make it even greater? Especially with a spare phone to experiment with before I attempt making any changes to my daily driver?

There are two main reasons I've been thinking about this. First, I would like to get a couple more version updates if possible, either because a custom ROM would allow me to install the update, or because the custom ROM is already one or two versions above Android 9 which is on my phone now. I need to keep this phone going for a couple more years, because frankly a current model flagship mobile isn't in the budget. And looking at the specs of midmarket and low-end handsets, it's clear that if I went that route I would be taking a huge hit in memory, storage, and processing. I don't want to step that far back.

The second reason is that I'd love to have a Nexus type ROM. I think it was even before I had the S5, when I was using a cheap LG Optimus if memory serves, when I tried out a Nexus type ROM, and the improvement was phenomenal. Unless something changes, the availability of this type of ROM to flash would be essential before I start making any changes.
 

mustang7757

Super Moderator
Moderator
Feb 6, 2017
91,590
6,174
113
Visit site
Well you have to look at a couple things, first are there Devs still dedicated to get custom roms still, I probably wouldn't think so do how old it is and rather put their time and effort on newer models can search XDA forums be the best place , 2nd if you just using it to tinker around with that's fine but as a daily driver nah it shouldn't have anymore security updates by this time and be risky for me to put personal information.

I have my One Plus 7T McLaren edition which stop getting security updates and won't go past Android 12 so took all my personal information off it and just a collector now .
 

Dark Penguin

Well-known member
Aug 21, 2011
414
2
18
Visit site
mustang7757 said:
Well you have to look at a couple things, first are there Devs still dedicated to get custom roms still, I probably wouldn't think so do how old it is and rather put their time and effort on newer models can search XDA forums be the best place
In this case, if there were developers building ROMs for this model two or three years ago, it would potentially be an improvement. Being able to run Android 11 would get me back into the "Old, still maintained" category for a little while at least.

I have my One Plus 7T McLaren edition which stop getting security updates and won't go past Android 12 so took all my personal information off it and just a collector now .

Does this mean you can't have anything sensitive on the device like banking apps, or your email accounts?
 

Dark Penguin

Well-known member
Aug 21, 2011
414
2
18
Visit site
I don't risk it

But doesn't that basically disable everything on the phone? I'm assuming this isn't your daily driver, right?

I'm hard put to think of anything you can do with a spare phone without having it logged into a Google account. For example, apps are associated with the account they were installed under.. Obviously you can't make phone calls on an out-of-contract phone, but if you have internet access you can use Google Voice if necessary.

What do you use this phone for, if you don't mind my asking?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Laura Knotek

mustang7757

Super Moderator
Moderator
Feb 6, 2017
91,590
6,174
113
Visit site
But doesn't that basically disable everything on the phone? I'm assuming this isn't your daily driver, right?

I'm hard put to think of anything you can do with a spare phone without having it logged into a Google account. For example, apps are associated with the account they were installed under.. Obviously you can't make phone calls on an out-of-contract phone, but if you have internet access you can use Google Voice if necessary.

What do you use this phone for, if you don't mind my asking?
I have 2 main accounts for my other devices so this one is linked to an account I have but don't care too much about it did have a sim in it awhile back. I'm a phone collector and this one is one of it's kind with the pop up camera and McLaren edition
 

FlameBison

New member
Feb 23, 2024
3
0
1
Visit site
Honestly, I mainly use this phone for its historical value. It's a rare McLaren edition with a unique pop-up camera design. Having it in my collection is more about appreciating its place in phone history than using it for everyday tasks. Thanks for your curiosity!
 

Forum statistics

Threads
943,201
Messages
6,917,777
Members
3,158,874
Latest member
dxter