Do you want to go into antennaegate? I'm not justifying the other poster's comments, but Apple suffers from defects, just like any other company. My roomie's iphone 3g didn't connect to GPS at all. Never got a lock. I asked him why he didn't take it back, he said, "I'll just wait for the iphone 4". Most likely, Engadget tried to get GPS lock indoors, which my Hero has trouble doing as well, but still works great in the car, when I actually need it. Who cares if you can't tell other people your long and lat while tweeting if google maps nav works just fine? We'll see how widespread the issue is at launch.
I agree that iphone suffers from defects and blind following that is a cult, but as far as antenna gate, the evo is just as bad, as are the galaxies for the same exact problem with the antennas and death grip, and the dinosaur blackberries actually are the least afefcted.