Hi I have an Active and while it basically is a great phone, I am really frustrated with the lack of updates. . . and also its kind of crummy voice phone quality… But your thread is about the lock screen and active key ;-)
I tried your situation on my phone --setting active key enabled on the lock screen -even though I normally don't have that enabled.
Oh, before my results, I would offer one comment on @Hanamizi's results. I would say that he is probably completely correct! However, he does not have a real security lock enabled. Swipe is not a security measure. So It can't be compared to password, face recognition, pattern, etc.
Based on my testing tonight, if you have any real security measure -like pattern or password, etc., even with the active key enabled, When you press the “active key” while the lock screen is showing, you FIRST will have to enter the password, or pattern, or visual, etc.
Anyway, that's how it works on my Active -using either pattern or password. I suspect that’s the normal Samsung implementation.
Oddly enough, even with a pattern lock screen set, I have two options showing on my lock screen -use the phone or use the camera.
- When I swipe the phone I am "allowed" to make an "emergency phone call" only.
- When I swipe the camera I am allowed to take pictures.
In both cases I don't have to enter the password! That makes it more convenient than the active key –if you have a locked screen! For example, my Active key is normally set to camera (quick press) and phone (long press), and if the screen is locked I see that I would have to enter the pattern first to use either! ;-(
Actually, I don’t really have that problem since I have my Gear S watch on my hand --and it is associated with the phone -so the phone is automatically unlocked when in contact with the phone. When I I press the active key for phone or photo I get to those apps normally without issue.
(In order to test the lock screen, I actually turned off my watch -so the lock screen was simulating most common users conditions).
In short, the Active key really does not add much to the lock screen –you still have to do your unlock measure. Try placing apps on the unlock screen –since I see that I can use photo and (emergency) phone when locked –even without unlocking. . .
Hope this helps! Have a great day!
Mark