I will be receiving a refurb replacement from Verizon on Friday. I was on the call for a loooong time today, and insisted on going above the original rep's head to her manager. She did all she could at her level, but I knew she wouldn't be authorized to go outside the systemic protocol that issues a refurb as a warranty replacement.
They (the original rep and the manager) kept trying to explain why the replacement was as is, that my other option would be to go directly through LG (send them the phone for repair), etc. The factor they kept leaving out of the equation is that my original G4 is on the Verizon installment payments.
I don't have an issue receiving a refurb as a warranty replacement generally, but I do have a problem paying installments on a new phone when I'm no longer using a new phone ("like new" and all that refurb language and "testing" they do is of no relevance to me).
Eventually the manager compromised on my original insistence that I get a new G4, since I was paying for one, by crediting two months worth of payments on my account.
While I still feel as though this is sort of slimy, it was enough of a compromise for me to accept, along with the refurb G4, as an acknowledgment that I'm not getting use of a new G4. I figure my time and effort it would require to continue pursuing that is worth something, too.
So, I don't have a warm and fuzzy feeling about it, but I'm not ticked either.