I have the Body Glove. The only complaint I have with it is the sides. It's raised but doesn't cover the screen, but it does make it a little difficult to type with sometimes.
Not a deal breaker though. And you get used to it pretty fast.
I'm still using the Body Glove and like it. However, the phone has fallen 2x and each time when it hits the ground, the case pops apart and comes off. So it is protected for the first hit, but naked for any subsequent impact. I've been lucky and no damage other than the tiniest of knicks in one corner.
Just something prospective buyers might want to keep in mind.