Just received my Otterbox Commuter case for the One. Firmer type of rubber for the inner shell which i like (doesn't collect as much lint/dust and feels more heavy duty). Same great hard outer shell. I like the smaller size of the Commuter over the Defender. All cutouts and buttons are exactly correct (nice area for power/IR blaster button). I wasn't going to use the included screen protector but I tried it and it doesn't affect any of the back or home button touch functionality in any way so I'll keep it on.