What the CEO of HTC didn't tweet was that they had to recall every phone that was shipped.
Why on earth would I make this up or how in the hell would I get a flyer if what I am saying is not true?
With all of the tech blogs following this story so closely, I'd have to believe that ONE of them would've ran a story on it if HTC had to recall their phones. The release on the 28th stories have been speculating either a software problem or they want to have enough units so they don't sell out (like with the Incredible). If it is a software issue, there is no need to recall the phones. Any issue could be fixed with an OTA update which could be done at time of activation or after.
If they recalled them for software they would have to pull every phone from every box, remove the plastic from each piece (phone, battery) power it on, do the update, repackage the pieces to look like new, and then reship them. They wouldn't go through all of that when they could do it OTA.
The only time I've ever heard of a phone recall is for hardware issues that can only be fixed by either the manufacturer or the carrier selling that phone. There's a reason manufacturers don't do recalls unless they have to, money. Companies this size are all about their bottom line, a recall is a last resort.
As far as why you would make this up, I don't know. Maybe you just take their word at face value. You ask why would you lie. The better question is what reason would they have to lie about this. They have an angry customer wanting to know where the phone they preordered is. They know they are going to have a lot of this until the phone is released. So they lie to get you out the door. I have had VZW & BB lie to me before, it happens. You saw an email explaining their story. How does an email trump screenshots or POs. It doesn't, they could all be faked. You choose to believe it, that's fine. But it is not any more believable than anything else we have seen so far. There's no reason to get this heated over speculation. It'll be here soon, deal with it.
P.S. I'm not saying that any of the screenshots or POs are fake, I'm only saying they can be faked. I value the info we have gotten from our insiders. Just saying if somebody wanted to they could do it.