SGS2 screen res isn't a deciding factor for some. The weight and battery life beat out the EVO3D, and arguably, some like the SAMOLED look better. And I'd almost say I'd prefer touchwiz just because the default dock is totally useless to me in sense (i do love the lock screen tho, sans the lack of custom background for it)
iPhone for simple minded? are you just troll baiting? I'm not a fan of iOS, but recognize it's very clean streamlined ecosystem. It usually does, in fact, just work. It's also the only phone that is powerful and still "small." I really wish someone would make that for a android. I'd even settle for just beefing up the Nexus S internals and screen, but keep the exact form factor and weight.
I can't speak for others but my battery life on my EVO3D is outstanding. Maybe I get about 1 hour less then my nephew's Sammy GS2...that I put on my contract.
I'm not too sure what you are talking about not being able to change backgrounds because I change mine every week.
The default dock may be useless to you, and i can understand that to a point.
But remember what I said in my original posting....with all the videos and reviews that I'm sure you looked at, then I'm sure that you tried the phone out at the store, how was the dock some how a suprise to you? In other words, did you just find out now that the dock was worthless to you now, after you got the phone? (or, like the original post asked "knowing then, what you know now, would you still have gotten the phone?) so you knew that you didn't like the dock back then before you got the phone, yet you bought it anyway...why?
Now I do like the amoled screen of the Samsung phones. But to disregard that the low res screen on such a large phone and the fact that the colors are clearly over saturated (never mind that the blacks may be awesome, but the whites just flat out suck), is to not fully tell the truth about the phone.
touchwiz vs sence...again, I'm not going to go into this because if you don't like sence, yet you bought it anyway, then I don't know what else to say.
As for the iPhone, yes It's powerful, but no more powerful then many of other small Android phones out there. The limits, and the lack of many features found on many of the top Android phones requires me to stand by my reply.
swiped to you in 3D