My Honest Take On The Charge Vs Thunderbolt Debate...Now That I Also Have A Charge

AndroidXTC

Well-known member
Oct 17, 2010
1,038
88
0
OK its really pretty simple as I see it and there is no real winner here. Lets start things off by build quality. Both phones look nice from a distance but the Thunderbolt looks more complex and expensive and the Charge looks more mass produced by a big electronics giant Hmmmm. I thought I would really like the real keys at the bottom vs the touch keys turns out I don't although the keys work nicely on the Charge it seems like having to push them in an unnecessary extra step in todays world. Power and volume buttons are much better on the Charge without a doubt. I do like the kickstand on the Thunderbolt it gives the handset a little extra feature that no one else has if you know what I mean.

Getting down to the nuts and bolts now on how they function is where the real difference is in my opinion. Now I have only used the Charge for one day but I can tell you this hands down the Charge just works better in almost every aspect. Not by a lot but its noticeable once you have used them both. First of all the Charge pushes 3rd party emails almost as fast as a Blackberry I'm still amazed my AOL mail arrives within 3 minutes every single time and Gmail is of course even faster. The video camera works much better on the Charge the sound is so loud and robust and clear that even after the Thunderbolts update it still makes the Thunderbolts level of volume poor. Battery life is slightly better on the Charge as well. The Charge's screen is amazing but the Thunderbolts isn't all that bad either.

Over all reception is about the same on both phones the signal bars are just about the same. Call quality on both phones just about the same. Touchwiz is laggy and just not as smooth as the HTCs sense. The Charge connects the hot spot faster and has a much better sub menu system for the hotspot it even tells you the devices names that are connected to it. Not to babble on and on my feelings are like this if you want a beautiful runway model in pretty pumps but sometimes forgets what planet she's on buy the Thunderbolt. If you want a pretty housewife that washes the floors and cooks you dinner and picks up the dog poo buy the Charge. So what am I really saying? They both work well but internally the Charge seems to work better, it's operating system seems to be more stable.
 
Last edited:
Interesting analysis. I actually had the charge for a week and traded it in for a Thunderbolt and couldn't be happier.

I found touchwiz slow and unresponsive. No copy and paste in their stock email client is inexcusable.

Have the Thunderbolt for about a week now and my gps locks well and no reboot issues.

This is my first Android experience and I'm pretty happy I made the switch from my iPhone 4 on AT&T.
 
Orange and brown theme, Touchwiz, physical buttons, no thanks. Not to mention the development community won't be near as good for the Charge as it is for the Bolt.

It's not for me, but if anyone is dissatisfied with their Bolt at least they have a viable option now on Verizon.
 
Your opinion isn't valid, you use AOL email. Sorry :(

LOL. I also wouldn't call the Charge a pretty housewife. I'd hate to have a housewife that is a lightweight and has no substance and looks cheap (i.e. the build quality of the Charge). Makes me think if they would fall down they would not be able to "just work" anymore.

I don't know why people act like the Thunderbolt doesn't just work. It just works perfectly fine for me. I know this is not the case for everyone obviously, but I wonder how much of the not "just working" is due to human error?
 
LOL. I also wouldn't call the Charge a pretty housewife. I'd hate to have a housewife that is a lightweight and has no substance and looks cheap (i.e. the build quality of the Charge). Makes me think if they would fall down they would not be able to "just work" anymore.

I don't know why people act like the Thunderbolt doesn't just work. It just works perfectly fine for me. I know this is not the case for everyone obviously, but I wonder how much of the not "just working" is due to human error?

Im not saying the Thunderbolt doesn't work im just saying in some aspects the Charge works better like the video playback volume quality for instance.
 
Last edited:
Ive had many customers bring the Charge back, completely unsatisfied, wanting nothing to do with Android anymore. And since Im such an awesome salesman, I get them to try the TBolt almost every time, and in my follow up calls, they are blown away. My opinion is and always has been Samsung does Android terribly. Most people who walk in my door with a customer service issue are almost always holding a Samsung or a Blackberry smartphone. Everything else by Samsung on the other hand is always pretty bomb.
 
  • Like
Reactions: broadwayblues
Im not saying the Thunderbolt doesn't work im just saying in some aspects the Charge works better like the video playback volume quality for instance.

Battery and email works fine for me. Besides these two an volume, anything else? If not, still the thunderbolt is a winner here.

Sent from my HTC Thunderbolt.
 
The Charge is nice in theory, but when it takes you 2 years to get an update, you'll see that's its not good at all plus it's a cheaply built phone.
 
Haha did you read your own review? After reading it, it seems like your 90% in favor of the tbolt, and think the email client is faster on the Charge, I gotta tell you though, my emails are literally near instant on my Bolt, honestly my gmail sometimes shows up on my phone before it shows up on my computer even when I'm hitting refresh... My exchange account is also pushed and is nearly instant.

Nothing would bother me more than a laggy interface, and the bolt is the fastest interface I've ever used on a phone hands down. Sense is great, especially when I lay launcher pro over it which imo has better widgets the only thing I miss is the clock because I haven't found one that is as good looking as the sense clock but everything else is so far superior that it's just worth it.

Enjoy whichever you choose, oh and the battery life is probably a little better because as I recall the charge comes with a bit bigger stock battery :)
 
Haha did you read your own review? After reading it, it seems like your 90% in favor of the tbolt, and think the email client is faster on the Charge, I gotta tell you though, my emails are literally near instant on my Bolt, honestly my gmail sometimes shows up on my phone before it shows up on my computer even when I'm hitting refresh... My exchange account is also pushed and is nearly instant.

Nothing would bother me more than a laggy interface, and the bolt is the fastest interface I've ever used on a phone hands down. Sense is great, especially when I lay launcher pro over it which imo has better widgets the only thing I miss is the clock because I haven't found one that is as good looking as the sense clock but everything else is so far superior that it's just worth it.

Enjoy whichever you choose, oh and the battery life is probably a little better because as I recall the charge comes with a bit bigger stock battery :)

This isn't meant to bash either phone its more or less my real world observation for now. The Thunderbolt is a great phone for sure.
 
Orange and brown theme, Touchwiz, physical buttons, no thanks. Not to mention the development community won't be near as good for the Charge as it is for the Bolt.

It's not for me, but if anyone is dissatisfied with their Bolt at least they have a viable option now on Verizon.

This.
 
isnt the charge's bootloader completely unlocked? Wouldnt that make it easier for developers? and if that is the case who cares when samsung updates......ya it stinks for people who dont want to root but not for everything else
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jerry Hildenbrand
isnt the charge's bootloader completely unlocked? Wouldnt that make it easier for developers? and if that is the case who cares when samsung updates......ya it stinks for people who dont want to root but not for everything else

updates = source code. Without source code the development is a crapshoot and because of that most of your developers will avoid a samsung device. I had the Fascinate prior to the Thunderbolt so I'm all too familiar with the issue.
 
updates = source code. Without source code the development is a crapshoot and because of that most of your developers will avoid a samsung device. I had the Fascinate prior to the Thunderbolt so I'm all too familiar with the issue.

Why is this? Isn't the Android platform pretty much the same? If this is the case whay does Google contract Samsung to make there branded handsets?