Personally I have hated Motorola phones. Their camera quality has lagged far behind, and the build quality.....I just don't see it. My wife's D2 has been a POS from Day 1. Can't wait to upgrade it for her. Not this phone definitely is eye candy. However, with ICS about to launch on the Nexus, I just don't know why I would go with this. It does look awesome.....but so did the original razr at the time compared to other cell phones. Turns out it was a big POS.
Reading where they said moto haters might like this, well I'll keep an open mind, but a non removable battery? I'm sure that's how they get it so thin, but even though my brother's iphone 4 surprises my Dinc in battery life, his still can't make it through a whole day with heavy use. Even if it does, or you need to be out late, you have to tether to a power cord. Sometimes that's just not an option. I need to have that extra battery for just in case moments.
It's nice to see something better from MOTO come along, but I still will hold out for the Nexus.