Thinking about trading my Note 8 for a Pixel 2 XL

[syphonsystem]

I've had both phones and I consider the note 8 a better device. Yes, the P2XL has a slightly better camera. However, audio recorded in videos is in mono and is very unimpressive. Also you lose the ability to apply themes, wireless charging, edge apps, the spen, slightly larger screen, MUCH better screen, tons of software features, and the note just looks better.

Honestly, my P2XL had a terrible screen.

Having had a S8+ and the pixel 2 XL. The screen was better on the Samsung but not buy much. I did buy my pixel in late November after the updates.

 

[Almeuit]

Oh boy... another discontented phone jumper. The Note 8 gives great pics and all around, phenomenal phone. Go ahead and jump OP. It's your MONEY! ������

And he is allowed to post his thoughts just like you can post your thoughts of love for the Note 8... no harm. .

 

[dov1978]

I really wanted the Black and White Pixel 2xl but got the Note instead as it covers way more bases than the Pixel. Everytime I see a TV ad for the Pixel 2 XL or see one in a store I'm still really drawn to it too but I need to keep reminding myself there's compromises with it that I just couldn't put up with for long like no One Handed Mode, no Pro camera controls or telephoto lens, no S-Pen of course, no separate app sound which I use daily on the Note and no wireless charging which is a huge miss when you're used to using it a lot.
The Note 8 is just too good to give up so I might try save up for a preowned Pixel 2 XL to use as my work phone or just to get it out my system because it's an itch that just isn't going away

 

[bassjo]

I'm in the same boat. I bought a 2xl to compare to the note. The ability to us with one hand is the my main thing. I love my note but damn that Pixel FLIES.

I know that your perspective of how fast your device is operating is relative but... I'd venture to say that Note 8 wipes the floor with pretty much any smartphone on the market currently, even pure Android stock. Not to mention that all the little extras that are standard on the Note 8 versus having to clutter up that new Pixel with apps to get you a similar experience. Finally don't take my word for it... https://youtu.be/aMQbRpxgFvs

Look at 13:12 for the MVP...

 

[Blues Fan]

Oh hell no! Crazy to even consider that. The Note 8 gives so much more. Wireless charging, Spen, no blue tint.

I'd even take the S8 Plus over the Pixel 2 xl.

 

[torbach1]

I understand the OP, and I also consider it every now and then. The XL 2 is a very nice device. But for me, it's particularly because I'm in Cyber security and there have been 2 seriously different and dangerous vulnerabilities recently (Blueborne and KRACK), that it took Samsung a while to ship updates for (the Note had the Blueborne fix on the official release day, but the S8/+ took another month, and they took almost all of December to ship the fix for KRACK, and so far afaik, only T-Mobile has that).

Samsung's inability to keep up to date on security updates even after Google has made it easier to do, is becoming more problematic as more exploits that don't require users to do something stupid like click on a potentially rogue link or install unknown apks come out.

Both Blueborne and KRACK could be installed on to your phone without you doing anything to allow it other than having Bluetooth (Blueborne) and WiFi (KRACK) turned on.

Granted, the attacker would have to be within 20 and 35 ft of you respectively, but someone could sit at a Starbucks and just infect everyone there. I'm a Target by default because i work in Cyber security and folks have been attacking cyber companies more.

Having said that, the screen issues have been significantly overblown with the Pixel XL 2 (after the fixes). The V30 has the same screen, and it's a great screen. No, it's not at the Note's level, but if you don't look at them side by side, you wouldn't notice.

The blue coloring is there to the same extent in the Note 8. Since I never use my phone whole looking at it from a 45 degree angle, I really don't see what the problem is.

The Pixel 2 XL in the store at least feels quicker than the Note and has significantly better battery life. I'm not switching yet, but if T-Mobile handn't released the December update yesterday, I would have seriously considered it due to he KRACK WiFi exploit (which Google resolve in the December update).

 

[mysamsungs7e]

how can you check for those Invaders?

 

[torbach1]

how can you check for those Invaders?

Android apps KRACK Scanner by Lambda Softwares and Blueborne Vulnerabilities Scanner by Armis.

 

[o4liberty]

I would compare the speed between the two devices first the note is much faster.

 

[05GT]

Don't do it. Just finished returning my P2XL this morning and repurchasing another Note 8.

 

[mgbosshogg]

Ahh I don't know. I love my note 8 but pixel 2 xl takes amazing pictures. Only owned it for 2 months.

Save the hassle and buy a £20 photography book.
The weak point is usually behind the lens, even with a cell phone.

 

[j_hansen]

in my book there's Note 8 and then there everything else, there is no other device out there that should be compared to the Note 8.... S8+...pixel2 and 2xl... iPong X.... LG V30 (I would like one of those) Essential phone, compare all of them but NOT to the Note 8 please.

 

[o4liberty]

Side by side no other device is faster the note Rocks!

 

[jlczl]

I understand the OP, and I also consider it every now and then. The XL 2 is a very nice device. But for me, it's particularly because I'm in Cyber security and there have been 2 seriously different and dangerous vulnerabilities recently (Blueborne and KRACK), that it took Samsung a while to ship updates for (the Note had the Blueborne fix on the official release day, but the S8/+ took another month, and they took almost all of December to ship the fix for KRACK, and so far afaik, only T-Mobile has that).

Samsung's inability to keep up to date on security updates even after Google has made it easier to do, is becoming more problematic as more exploits that don't require users to do something stupid like click on a potentially rogue link or install unknown apks come out.

Both Blueborne and KRACK could be installed on to your phone without you doing anything to allow it other than having Bluetooth (Blueborne) and WiFi (KRACK) turned on.

Granted, the attacker would have to be within 20 and 35 ft of you respectively, but someone could sit at a Starbucks and just infect everyone there. I'm a Target by default because i work in Cyber security and folks have been attacking cyber companies more.

Having said that, the screen issues have been significantly overblown with the Pixel XL 2 (after the fixes). The V30 has the same screen, and it's a great screen. No, it's not at the Note's level, but if you don't look at them side by side, you wouldn't notice.

The blue coloring is there to the same extent in the Note 8. Since I never use my phone whole looking at it from a 45 degree angle, I really don't see what the problem is.

The Pixel 2 XL in the store at least feels quicker than the Note and has significantly better battery life. I'm not switching yet, but if T-Mobile handn't released the December update yesterday, I would have seriously considered it due to he KRACK WiFi exploit (which Google resolve in the December update).

Ok seems you’re the best person to ask then. Is there any known use of these vulnerabilities on any of the millions of recent Android handsets and if there has been what is the reach of the attack? I read people describe scenarios where smartphones are at risk but I have not heard of any news reports on any of these exploits actually causing issues for anyone. I’m not saying it can’t happen but what are the real chances of it happening? This is a serious question because as of right now I don’t care to pick a stripped down phone like a Pixel based on a one in a hundred million chance when I can choose a feature packed Note 8 instead, but I would definitely consider it if the odds are more like one in a thousand.

 

[andrew_ackley]

The pixel XL 2 screen is about as good as the notes after the update just FYI. Just a little smaller.

 

[barondebxl]

2 great phones. If you feel like it then go for it.

 

[Lepa79]

in my book there's Note 8 and then there everything else, there is no other device out there that should be compared to the Note 8.... S8+...pixel2 and 2xl... iPong X.... LG V30 (I would like one of those) Essential phone, compare all of them but NOT to the Note 8 please.

I shake my head when I see all these YouTube videos with titles "Should you upgrade from S8 Plus to Note 8?" Two different product lines, if you are moving from S8 to Note 8, you are "switching" products NOT upgrading.
Total agree with you. Note series is a beast of it's own. No other phone on the market can be compared to Note 8. People just don't get it. Pixel 2 XL and many other flagship phones are ALL GREAT phones. They are just not a Note and can't be compared to the Note product line.

 

[recDNA]

For $996 on Amazon you can get the Nikon D7200 with two lenses and a case, and it takes AMAZING pictures. Phones take pictures for sure, you can also get Microsoft Word on the phone and type a 1000 page novel... Is it the best way? The camera is my last consideration when buying a phone because in relation to a real camera they still suck.

Just trying to save you the buyer's remorse that's sure to come. haha

I have a Nikon SLR with multiple lenses however it is seldom with me when I see something extraordinary to photograph. Then I have to remember to charge the battery etc. 99% of my photos are taken with the phone because it is ALWAYS with me.

 

[AustinTech]

The pixel XL 2 screen is about as good as the notes after the update just FYI. Just a little smaller.

Nah man, not even close. Maybe you don't mind the look, but saying it's as good as the Note 8 is ridiculous.

 

[andrew_ackley]

Nah man, not even close. Maybe you don't mind the look, but saying it's as good as the Note 8 is ridiculous.

Bro I have both side by side right now. Do you? I have better than 20-15 vision come on. If that makes you feel better fine. Merry Christmas.