You're still missing the point. The power of the general masses (verified owners) will always be greater than that of a single individual especially when it comes to matters of opinion. I know Tyll (repairman turned editor) & his wall of fame, and I wouldn't call head-fi trusted either. Fact of the matter is that anyone with the right equipment can become a glorified reviewer.
At that price, picking an off shore brand name over a well established brand like Sennheiser is shameful. Don't get me wrong, the Ether's open back or even the new closed back variant are pretty good, but not enough to start poking at the establishment. I actually had a loaner a few months ago (Ether Flow). Right off the bat, the dynamic punch/sound stage is no where near the HD800S or even the T5p, more so close to the HD598 but a little more refined with a mild V shape sound signature to boost the bass & treble.
There's a bunch of kick starter efforts for the headphone market out there, and Mr Speaker are no different. If these were priced closer to the 900-1000 range, they would be something to consider.