cmandd, (just back from the weekend), I completely see where you are coming from, and normally I would agree. But I am a regular customer, I am in there all the time buying new phones for our business and home use over the years, I know many of the reps by name, and I have NEVER complained about a phone issue. I have worked out many minor issues with various reps and always in a pleasant and reasonable manner.
When my daughter dropped her Thunderbolt and cracked the screen, I took it in to see if they had any suggestions for manually fixing it, but decided in the end just to buy her a new Maxx since she was due for an upgrade anyway. It never even occurred to me to try to pressure them into replacing it. That was something she did to the phone.
So, when I told the manager that there was a problem from the beginning (I remember now that from day one she had to figure out how to prop up the phone while charging to make a good connection, I figured it was a bad cord and meant to get her a new one, but forgot about it), I actually DID expect them to believe me and just accept that fact as true. Whether that would mean anything legally since it had been three months, I don't know, but I did expect them to just accept that as a fact and then bend over backwards to see how they could resolve the issue to our benefit. If the manager had taken that approach, seemed truly concerned and regretful that they had sold us a defective product, etc, I would have had an ENTIRELY different reaction, even if the end result was the same.
I was dealing with someone new and, unfortunately, someone in charge. The rest of the regular reps seemed very uncomfortable. She dug in her heels immediately, got very defensive and dismissive and had no interest in helping the customer get the best possible outcome.
We will be getting the phone in today, and I do wish I had asked whether it would be refurbished or new one. I guess we will see.