Son of a bish! Well now I don't know what to do. It's not that it's a feature that makes of breaks the phone but when I take the sum o things VZW has done with this phone from delayed launch, logo on home button, locked bootloader, and now this, I just can't bring myself to support that by buying it. It's the principle of it. Ill probably either pass or look at moving my five lines to AT&T. The SGS III has the feature, why screw with it.
sorry for going off topic with such a long message...
JoJo,
I know you say that the continuous scrolling home screens are not a make or break feature but that would really cause you to not get the GN2 or leave Verizon?
You indicated that it is one of 4 factors:
1.) Delayed launch:
This is a business decision based on a couple of factors:
A.) Commitment to launch window for Verizon Exclusive Droid Brand
When AT&T had an exclusive relationship with Apple for the iPhone Verizon partnered with a few Android phone manufacturers to create the Droid Brand.
That brand was the marketing foundation for fighting the iPhone and Verizon is committed to supporting that brand.
Samsung has committed to a business strategy of being a volume brand and sell more devices than any other manufacturer.
They are going to leverage their brands and platforms and sell them through whatever channel is willing. The Galaxy Note 2 is being launched on just about every US carrier (5 to be exact) and numerous around the world.
Verizon is not in the business to sell phones. They want to use phones as a draw to bring more subscribers to it's network and keep those subscribers to use their service. It can do that with exclusive phones that are not available on other networks.
If an AT&T customer really wants the GN2 they just get it on AT&T, there is no reason to even look at Big Red.
But if an AT&T customer is smitten with a Droid RAZR MAXX HD or Droid DNA they will have to come to Verizon.
So there was a scheduling conflict with Verizon and Samsung.
Samsung planned a US launch of the GN2 for the end of October while Verizon committed a wide exclusive window to launch the RAZR Family (M, RAZR HD, RAZR MAXX HD). Because the Razr M was brand new they launched it first and gave a large exclusive window of several weeks. The HD, and MAXX HD was then launched exclusively through early November. Even the Droid DNA was moved ahead of the GN2 because it is exclusive and has a larger potential market on VZW.
As much as I like the GN2, it is still a niche product. The 5.5" Phablet is just too big for some and too expensive for others. It will not bring subscribers (as will the RAZR Family and DNA) and most of the Verizon GN2 sales will be cannibalized from other VZW devices.
So in terms of a "BUSINESS DECISION", would you have launched the GN2 before the Droids?
B.) Software update:
All of the GN2's had to be updated to enable the Dual View Multi-task windows.
All of the other US carriers launched without this feature and will have to do an Over The Air update to enable.
At this point Sprint has completed this update and AT&T has not (I'm not sure about US Cellular & T-Mobile).
The launch delay has allowed Verizon to do an in house update. As a customer with experience waiting for the super conservative Verizon to send out OTA updates, I much prefer they do it in house and have it available at launch.
AT&T launched earlier but they will not have the dual view multi-task feature available when the GN2 launches on VZW tomorrow.
2.) Logo on home button:
There is a carrier logo on every phone of every US carrier. Every manufacturer knows the logo will be applied. Do they really care where? Apple does. The others, not so much.
My Thunderbolt has a Verizon logo at the top center of the phone and the HTC logo on the back.
Samsung took the top center position on the GN2 so instead of the back Verizon took the bottom center position which happens to be the home button.
Would it be better if the positions were reversed?
Verizon would much prefer the top center position.
If it bothers you that much I'm sure finger nail polish remover will remove the logo.
3.) As far as the locked bootloader:
If you are a person that likes to root your phone that could be a factor if that is your passion.
But VZW is a very conservative company and they try to protect their customers and the network.
Rooting the phone invalidates the warranty and reports are that it disables the S-Pen with the GN2.
They also believe there is the possibility of rooted phones impacting their network.
4.) As for the continuously scrolling home pages:
I'm not sure there is a logical reason to disable this feature. There is some thought that it is related to the software update to enable the dual view multi-view feature.
I would be interested to see if Sprint (or International) GN2's retained the feature following their OTA updates. Or if it impacts the AT&T units whenever they receive their update.
Even if Big Red is the only carrier not to have continuously scrolling home pages I will not leave the best LTE network in the country.
It will take a little more than that.
Again, Sorry for going off topic with such a long message.