I am with you. The Note 8 is really that good. The only things I can find myself criticizing are the height of the device and the fingerprint sensor. When I compare the size of the Pixel 2 XL, it is not much shorter than the Note 8. I ordered the XL, but I am really struggling with justifying the order. I have tried many devices and when I ask myself why would I set aside the Note 8 to use this device (fill in the blank), I cannot justify the change. When I think about the fact that I paid about $500 for the Note 8 with the trade in for Note 7 buyers, there really is no phone that can top it for the money.
I am a phone junkie and have literally tried about every phone (some several times) and when I think about just sticking with one device it is hard, but when I really try to justify a change, it just makes sense to stick with the Note 8.