Ok, I see this thread has been abandoned for over a week, but hopefully some of y'all are still watching it.
I've read most of this thread, read 100's of descriptions and reviews on Amazon, and I still feel like I'm not finding what I want (perhaps it doesn't exist?!).
So background: I had a Droid X2 for forever. I'm not a gadget person and don't get excited about "the next new thing," so I was reluctant to get a new phone...I don't like change! The X2 was getting worse and worse performance and battery-life wise. In doing some research, VZW's LG G2 sounded like a phone I'd like. I had the Otterbox on my X2 and it was AMAZING. I think it's the first phone I've ever had that I didn't have to do an insurance claim on! People often commented on how big my phone was, but anyone who knows me is aware of the fact that I'm constantly dropping things, tripping, and carry a huge purse full of things that could damaged a phone. The Otterbox made me feel like my phone was safe from ME! I need this kind of security in my life.
So, as I'm planning the purchase of the G2, imagine my surprise with the issues on the Otterbox! I have looked and looked and looked for something similar. I ended up getting the G2 before I could find a case and have been carrying it around like an egg, with all the stickers still on it. I ordered this case:
Amazon.com: OEM VERIZON BLACK SHELL CASE BELT CLIP HOLSTER COMBO + STAND FOR LG VS980 VS 980: Cell Phones & Accessories because it had a kickstand, a belt-clip case, and, most importantly, a very clumsy person I know has the same one for their iPhone and they haven't had issues.
I HATE this one after having my awesome Otterbox for so long! In reading "...The holster was molded to fit the phone face-inward to protect the lcd screen...," I naively never imagined they meant it could ONLY face inward. The X2's Otterbox allowed me to turn it screen-in and screen-out whenever necessary. The clip fits VERY snug and it's extremely difficult to pull the phone out of the holster to answer a call. I've missed every call where my phone was being "protected" since I've been using this case. The kickstand is very difficult to use and makes me feel like I'm going to break it, opening or closing. The X2's Otterbox's kickstand WAS the belt clip. Now, I'll admit, I broke it fidgeting with it one day, but I had had the case so long at that point (at least 3/4 of the time I had the phone...which was a LONG time in phone years), I still consider Otterbox tough enough for people like me. The covering for this definitely doesn't
feel as sturdy as my Otterbox at all. The volume/power/camera area is pretty exposed and none of the ports are covered. And, as with almost all the cases available for the G2, there's no built-in screen protector. I was told by Verizon Reps and many friends with new phones that the screen protectors are "unnecessary"..."all the new cases are made so the screen doesn't touch a surface when flat-faced on a surface"...Really? I've never had a phone case that allowed the screen to touch a flat surface...I'm concerned about the screen protection when I have to toss the thing into my purse! I peeled the film off the screen when I put it into the case and while I don't feel like the G2's screen gets smudged as easily as the X2 for whatever reason, I'm still a neat freak and I need my screen to be safe, covered, and clean.
Basically, everything I loved about my Otterbox are complete negatives about this case as well as plenty of the other cases I've researched...in fact, receiving this case has made me notice the issues with other cases even more. And, as most of you know, the Otterbox for the VZW version of the G2 is apparently crap!
My question is, what to do?! I'm hoping someone here in all of their testing and trying out cases can give some advice. I'm not the type to order 10 cases and audition them--I want to know what works and stick with it!
What I NEED:
#1 SAFETY -- Otterbox level safety! Meaning double layer (hard and soft) cover. Port covers. I understand most cases don't do the built-in screen cover, so I'd be willing to compromise if someone has an awesome suggestion for a protector that goes with a cover without pulling at the sides where it would have to be replaced all the time...I'd still prefer built-in if possible, though.
#2 Kickstand -- I really appreciate being able to look at things on the screen with the phone propped up on a surface. I would prefer that the kickstand be attached to a holster.
#3 Holster -- A holster serves two purposes for me personally: an extra layer of protection in the case of drops and something to add bulk (I realize how ridiculous that sounds since most people would like to keep their phone as small as possible). There are several things that float around in my purse that are the same size/weight...the holster case immediately sets my phone apart when blindly reaching in and shuffling things around. I have used the belt clip for it's intended purpose, but safety and feel are more important to me. A holster should allow me to "flip" the phone in the holster...I don't want a holster where the phone can only face "in"...
#4, etc...General User Preferences -- I prefer black for the color. Whatever the outside finish, it should be very "grippy." As little exposed hard plastic on the case as possible...it just seems too easy to break and I don't like the breaking-up of the finish/"feel" of the phone.
I know I sound insanely picky, but the fact is, Otterbox spoiled me. My phone was well-protected and the case and holster really met my needs and preferences. Ignoring the G2's Otterbox as an option, does anyone have any suggestions?! Much thanks in advance!