I've been pretty vocal about my disappointment over the prospect of a bottom-firing speaker(s) on the Nexus Marlin this year, in favor of front stereo speakers. I was just in an AT&T store, however. I wanted to experience for myself the sound on the HTC 10 to see what it might be like on the Nexus.
While the store didn't have the 10, it did have the A9, which of course, has the bottom speaker . The sound through my Samsung headset was unreal. It was just richer and fuller in quality, even at the highest volume, which was very loud, but with no distortion at all. I definitely could tell a difference between it and the 6P at the highest volume. Call me convinced.
I love my 6P, but I can admit when I'm wrong. I'm no longer sour on a bottom- firing speaker, assuming HTC has control over the audio of the phone. Only in that case would those of us that value sound on a phone be convinced about not having the dual front stereo set up.
Posted via the Android Central App
Not sure if I'm reading your post correctly, but you used your Samsung headset to listen to the audio from the A9? If that's the case, then it's got nothing to do with the bottom firing speaker.
As far the the Marlin/Sailfish goes - sure dual front-facing speakers is preferable (assuming the quality is good), but I can live with a bottom firing speaker I guess. It's annoying to cup your hand around, but I think there are bigger fish to fry when it comes to phones than just audio.
The Nexus 6P doesn't sound as good as the HTC One M7/M8/M9, so I personally don't care if the next Nexus phone(s) don't have front facing speakers - they never had best in class speakers anyway.
To me, the design is of more interest, and I can't say I'm sold on the design that leaked out on Android Police a week ago. Not sure why the back has a huge glass/plastic pane, the bezels in the renders do look quite large, considering there's no dual front-firing speakers and no fingerprint scanner at the front. I do like that there is no camera bulge, but that looks like a small win to me on a set of phones that...look like a bit of a mess to me.
Specs to me seem fine. Rumoured to now have the Snapdragon 821, which is fine. 4gb ram is plenty and the Marlin having a 5.5" screen a 3450mah battery sounds decent, though I don't know why they're unable to match the Galaxy S7 Edge's 3600mah. I'll put money on the 5.5" Nexus having larger dimensions than the Galaxy S7 Edge and yet still has a smaller battery capacity.
Won't know for certain until it's official, but that's my gut instinct. And while the design hasn't wow'd me, I didn't like the Nexus 6P design when it was leaked, but came to be ok with it once I got it.