So yeah, there's no winning. Next year I take my chance on Samsung.com for sure. I'm having Aura Blue envy big time, by the way, but of course AT&T didn't offer it until after my order couldn't be canceled. Anyway, I used the live chat feature and within minutes the rep. claimed my order is on track to be delivered tomorrow - yet it hasn't shipped and I'm in Alaska sooo... - but then noted I too have an activation failed. I expressed concern that BestBuy never notified me in any way, I was contacting purely out of concern that my order was delayed. He said no, the phone will arrive it just means they had an issue activating it with my carrier. The only emails I've received from BestBuy were my confirmation, and recently they sent 2x of the same mobile agreement emails.
I don't entirely know what that means yet, possibly just that I have to call and do it myself when the phone arrives. Frankly, that's normal to me? I've only done pick-up in store where they do it for you, but it's the same painful hold process for everyone, BestBuy has no special alternative phone number or anything. The BestBuy rep. assured me AT&T could easily fix it if I call, and provided 800-331-0500. I was thinking I'd just slap my old SIM in, so I may just wait and see when the phone arrives.
I will say, my online chat rep. was responsive and nice about it, no painful wait.