Evo 3d vs. Galaxy s2

Re: Switching to sgsII when it comes out

Just out of curiosity, how do you guys get new phones every few weeks. Do you just sell your evo for like $300 and just pay the difference for a new SG on ebay??
 
Re: Switching to sgsII when it comes out

ya man pretty much...ebay or there are all ways people around you will to buy it all.
 
Re: Switching to sgsII when it comes out

WARNING: Rant. 3 months of frustration and I think I deserve to vent a little.

I absolutely am switching over to the SGSII. While the 3vo has some awesome perks like qHD and 3D camera (which I can live without), I simply can't take any longer how buggy this phone is. Sense 3.0 is laggy and the carousel effect is annoying as friggin hell. Can't use any other launchers though because for some reason, they're even laggier than Sense and laggier than when I use them on my Evo 4g. The camera is pitiful, sorry, I don't have 3 minutes to pause and adjust settings every time I want to take a photo, with them to only come out mediocre at best (and yes, I know how to adjust ISO and all that jazz). And after the 2.3.4 update, my battery life on my phone has dropped TREMENDOUSLY, arguably worse than my 4g or at the very least on par. I get maybe 5 hours, 6 hours tops with medium usage. In fact, I have screens of my phone on 40% brightness, app backup/restore off, auto rotation off, and only getting 4 hours, 51 minutes of power. I used to get 16 or more hours when I first got the phone, what the hell happened?

HTC's CIQ thing or whatever it's called, the app that tracks your every move, is another deal breaker for me. They're denying that it is tracking your data and claiming it's an opt-in, but developers who've cracked that thing say otherwise.

The bootloader unlocker that they promised us was a joke. Waited 2 months for that crap, was so excited to root, but unfortunately cannot for the time being. Maybe in another 2 months? 3? No thanks.

I used to love the form factor until I compared the phone with my friend's Sensation. What the hell, HTC? I feel so low-balled for giving the 3D such a crap design. I know you can do better, YOU know you can do better, everyone knows you can do better. The back of my phone is already warped because of the crap aluminum ring around the cameras and my shutter button jiggles around loosely.

I'm just so fed up with HTC. Had a Mytouch 3g, got rid of it for a Nexus One. Loved the development but seriously, no multi-touch? How the hell did they F that up? Said screw that and went to the Evo 4g. Put up with the nasty phone design and bugs since I rooted anyways and got an extended battery. Put up with the ******ed 30 fps cap for months. How the hell did they overlook that? Why is it when every HTC phone is released, there seems to be major, negligent, oversights in its design? Hoped that the Evo 3D had everything I would want in a phone: great build quality, great camera, great screen, great form factor, great software, great development. I can honestly say after 3 months of owning this thing, I have good to mediocre to poor on each of those. And with Sense 3.5 looking butt ugly, I have no faith that this phone is getting better, it's going to get worse over time.

Not to mention, HTC rarely shows faithfulness to their phones when they are releasing new phones every week. Like the HTC Amaze 4g. Really? That should've been what the Sensation and 3vo is. I'm just getting tired of HTC cutting corners and pushing out half-baked phones. With 6 months already of tried and tested confirmation of quality from the SGS2, I'm definitely going to make the switch come September 16. Sorry HTC, but I've had 4 of your phones already, it's time for me to move on.
 
Last edited:
Re: Switching to sgsII when it comes out

I'm so glad I held off on the 3D, after the problems I had with my EVO 4G, it looks like its just more of the same with the 3D.

I sold my EVO and got a Nexus S (Not through Sprint)....I'll be waiting till October/November to see what Sprint pushes this winter before making my upgrade decision.
 
Re: Switching to sgsII when it comes out

With 6 months already of tried and tested confirmation of quality from the SGS2, I'm definitely going to make the switch come September 16. Sorry HTC, but I've had 4 of your phones already, it's time for me to move on.

You do know the SGS2 that's been out for 6 months isn't what you're getting right? They're new US versions that don't have mass testing confirmation that makes you feel so warm and fuzzy.
 
Re: Switching to sgsII when it comes out

You do know the SGS2 that's been out for 6 months isn't what you're getting right? They're new US versions that don't have mass testing confirmation that makes you feel so warm and fuzzy.

Um, obviously? But there's aspects of the phone that you know are going to be the exact same as the UK SGS2, such as the camera quality, the UI, similar form factor and build quality, the display being super AMOLED plus, etc. etc. Lol, I like how attacking a phone has caused you to attack a person.
 
Re: Switching to sgsII when it comes out

Um, obviously? But there's aspects of the phone that you know are going to be the exact same as the UK SGS2, such as the camera quality, the UI, similar form factor and build quality, the display being super AMOLED plus, etc. etc. Lol, I like how attacking a phone has caused you to attack a person.

Explain exactly how asking a question is attacking a person? If throwing out some bullcrap statement like that is your attempt to stifle conversation then you've failed. And you need to look up what attack means and revise your understanding of the word. Not an attack.....just a suggestion.
 
Re: Switching to sgsII when it comes out

Explain exactly how asking a question is attacking a person? If throwing out some bullcrap statement like that is your attempt to stifle conversation then you've failed. And you need to look up what attack means and revise your understanding of the word. Not an attack.....just a suggestion.

It's called you making smug passive-aggressive implications that my opinion is invalid because the only reason why anybody would like Phone B over Phone A is because of some sort of emotional response; "warm and fuzzy" as you put it, not because of anything logical or reasonable. Except everything in my post was based on experience and reason, something fanboys seem to omit and pretend that doesn't exist so they can justify their purchase.

Instead of respecting my opinion or at the very least give a decent rebuttal, you fabricate a straw-man argument against me by pointing out something fallaciously obvious (like the US and overseas versions being different) as a means to derail my points altogether and invalidate my opinion as to why I think the Evo is an inferior phone all while attributing baseless emotion to my argument rather than valid observation.

Troll harder, kid.
 
Last edited:
I have had absolutely no problems with the EVO 3D except those caused by the PRL update. This is a great time to be upgrading. No phone is going to right for everyone. There is no need to criticize anyone for his or her choice.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gonk24
I have had absolutely no problems with the EVO 3D except those caused by the PRL update. This is a great time to be upgrading. No phone is going to right for everyone. There is no need to criticize anyone for his or her choice.

you're obviously a grownup lol, too many fanbois in here
 
Re: Switching to sgsII when it comes out

It's called you making smug passive-aggressive implications that my opinion is invalid because the only reason why anybody would like Phone B over Phone A is because of some sort of emotional response; "warm and fuzzy" as you put it, not because of anything logical or reasonable. Except everything in my post was based on experience and reason, something fanboys seem to omit and pretend that doesn't exist so they can justify their purchase.

Instead of respecting my opinion or at the very least give a decent rebuttal, you fabricate a straw-man argument against me by pointing out something fallaciously obvious (like the US and overseas versions being different) as a means to derail my points altogether and invalidate my opinion as to why I think the Evo is an inferior phone all while attributing baseless emotion to my argument rather than valid observation.

Troll harder, kid.

Project much? You have some anger issues you need to iron out if you got all that from my comments. I stated fact about the US versions of SGS2, nothing to do with the Evo 3D or your precious opinion on the 3D the other HTC products you've owned. Can you point to the specific instances where your opinion on HTC products was disrespected? Nope, because I didn't mention it. I simply stated that the US versions of the SGS2 don't have 6 months of tried and tested confirmation of quality. That's 100% accurate regardless of the same parts inside each version. The "warm and fuzzy" comment goes to your comfort and confidence in a product, which is based on a different product. Nothing to do with invalidating your opinion. In fact, I didn't even read through your chapter on why HTC is the devil.

I've owned an Android device for a little over a month. I don't think that gets me fanboy (or troll for that matter) status yet just based on time put in to date. Lol...kid....you're funny. I myself chose to not wait for the SGS2 based solely on the UI. I personally don't find it attractive like sense. But that's MY opinion and you are welcome to have the opposite view.
 
I have had absolutely no problems with the EVO 3D except those caused by the PRL update. This is a great time to be upgrading. No phone is going to right for everyone. There is no need to criticize anyone for his or her choice.

Thanks for the PRL fix info over on that thread. It saved me today after flashing CleanROM.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CarrieK
Re: Switching to sgsII when it comes out

Project much? You have some anger issues you need to iron out if you got all that from my comments. I stated fact about the US versions of SGS2, nothing to do with the Evo 3D or your precious opinion on the 3D the other HTC products you've owned. Can you point to the specific instances where your opinion on HTC products was disrespected? Nope, because I didn't mention it. I simply stated that the US versions of the SGS2 don't have 6 months of tried and tested confirmation of quality. That's 100% accurate regardless of the same parts inside each version. The "warm and fuzzy" comment goes to your comfort and confidence in a product, which is based on a different product. Nothing to do with invalidating your opinion. In fact, I didn't even read through your chapter on why HTC is the devil.

I've owned an Android device for a little over a month. I don't think that gets me fanboy (or troll for that matter) status yet just based on time put in to date. Lol...kid....you're funny. I myself chose to not wait for the SGS2 based solely on the UI. I personally don't find it attractive like sense. But that's MY opinion and you are welcome to have the opposite view.

See, this is my problem with you. Instead of making points and rebutting them, you keep using ad hominem because you don't have anything of substance to say. Instead of saying why you agree/disagree, you attack my character as a means to invalidate my opinion rather than making reasonable counter points. Looks more like you're the one stifling conversation, not me. All I wanted to do was explain my frustrations with this phone and HTC for reasons why I switch, and you attack my character and then accuse ME of stifling conversation? LOL.

In your first response, you summarized my reasons for switching phones as me being emotional or "warm and fuzzy". In your second response, you call my statements "bullcrap". In your third response, you attribute to me anger problems. None of these three responses I listed have anything to do with phones or android, they are just with you having a problem with me and attacking me rather than promoting a conversation about PHONES. That's why I'm pissed. At the very least, I appreciated your last few sentences in your last post since it was actually constructive.

And yeah, you can be a fanboy long before you ever even actually own the device. There are Apple fanboys who defend the precious image of Apple long before they even own a single Apple product. Duration of ownership =/= level of fanboyism. And if you're going around making passive-aggressive, sarcastic, ad hominem attacks on people in a PHONE forum of all places, then yes that makes you a troll. Fact is, instead of just whining about the phone and saying that it sucks like so many others do, I actually gave reasons why I was unhappy with it. And they're valid reasons. Too bad by your own admission, you skipped that part and didn't even read it. If you didn't read it, why the hell are you responding?

Back to PHONES, had you actually read my "chapter on why HTC is the devil", maybe you would've empathized when you've been with a company who has consistently cut corners for the 2 years and 4 devices you've had with them, you have every right to throw in the towel and say you've at least tried to enjoy their products and that it's time for something new. As far as the "tried and tested" remark, it was for the SGS2 brand, not the SPECIFIC device I am looking to switch to. And regardless of how insignificantly different the overseas version of the SGS2 is in comparison to the US one (since the only difference is CDMA radios, WIMAX and form factor), the SGSII has won and earned many high ratings, excellent reviews, etc, and the minor differences between the US and overseas versions aren't going to dramatically different. Therefore, I expect the phone to be just as good, if not better thanks to the additional features like the notification light and slightly larger screen (my preference) that the original SGS2 doesn't have.

The Evo 3D got consistently bad reviews before the phone came out, and I along with many others defended this phone to the death ignoring the warning signs that were foretold to us of the device. So this time, I'm going to go by the reviews, benchmarks, and video and photo samples. If the E4GT is anywhere near the build quality, benchmarks, camera quality, and screen quality of it's overseas counterpart, I think I will be happy for a little while.

Yes, the UI isn't as attractive as Sense, I agree. But Touchwiz does have some benefits over Sense, like resizeable widgets, a cleaner menu to add widgets, no carousel, and a slider to quickly move between homescreens and "app pages" in the drawer. I find the sliders way more practical to move quickly between homescreens than that damn carousel effect on Sense.

Don't get me wrong, despite my ranting, I think the Evo 3D is a great device, but it didn't live up to the hype and expectations I had for it. Maybe it's just not for me anymore. If you own one, that's great, I don't really care since it's your phone and you're the one whose going to be happy/disappointed with it.
 
I love my Evo 3D, but I can understand your frustrations with HTC. I totally forgot about that 30 fps cap thing back when the Evo first came out, or the fake HDMI out fiasco. I was really unhappy about that when I first got my Evo 4g. Made me second guess HTC for a minute there. I'm not too happy about the bootloader situation either. Nonetheless, I think the Evo 3D is a great phone with tons of customization you can do to it to make the phone work as you want it to. You don't have to be stuck with what the manufacturers tell you you have to use. That's the beauty of Android. However, if things you can't change like the screen, form factor, and camera are important to you, then I suppose you should give the Epic touch a try. Evo 3D, Bionic, Epic Touch, they're all good and you can't really go wrong with these recently released superphones. But seriously, I think you need to chill, lol.
 
I currently have the EVO 4G and I'm thinking about upgrading in a few months. The EVO 4G has been an awesome and solid phone for me and I have loved it but looking at the EVO 3D I'm turned off by two things. First, the whole 3D thing is a stupid gimmick and a waist of hardware space in my opinion. Second, I will not buy a smartphone with the USB port located on the side of the phone. With as much as these phones have to be charged it's a royal pain in the @$$ to have to talk on the phone and charge it at the same when the cord is sticking out the side of it!! (and yes I do have a Bluetooth headset but most of the time I prefer not using it unless I'm going to be on the phone for a long time) HTC I really hope you SEE this post and listen!! For me it's not a worthwhile upgrade to the EVO 3D from my EVO 4G, especially with the location of the USB port.

Now the Galaxy has some really great features over the EVO 3D that I like... screen, processor, storage, and USB port on bottom... but the one thing that holds me back is TouchWiz. I really don't like TouchWiz compared to Sense. The over all look of Sense is way better and more tasteful in my opinion and I love the Sense widgets, especially the full size calendar widgets... TouchWiz just looks too cartoony and too much like Iphones for my tastes.

If I had to choose between these two phones right now I'd go with the Galaxy because in my opinion it's more of an upgrade for me and, most of all, I won't buy the EVO with the USB port one the side of them phone. But I might just end up waiting to see what HTC has to offer next.
 
See ya evo 3d hello sgsii

Well it's been real evo 3d... Samsung won me over and you are going up for sale asap as soon as I get my phone tommorrow..... Who else is getting a the galaxy s 2?
 
Re: See ya evo 3d hello sgsii

Not me, but hope you like it. I like the screen but other than that I like the Evo better.
 
Not i, love my evo 3d. My 3d along with my 10.1,32 gig tab i should be all set for quite a while. Just curious, does anyone know what this new phone can do that the EVO 3d can't do? Or pretty much any other new phone for that matter?

Sent from my GT-P7510 using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:

Trending Posts

Forum statistics

Threads
956,944
Messages
6,970,750
Members
3,163,664
Latest member
jochu