I'm "over rating Doze's impact?" i mean, did you even read my response? lol. where exactly did i say that?
most of that 7%, pretty much all of it actually, is on standby ... also it drips quicker from 100% to 80% and 20% to 0% then in between. point is, while I'm at work or if I'm not using it 3-4 hours, that extra 15% could make a huge difference. I mean, of its only 10% I lose, and M plus a more efficient phone can give me another 10% that means instead of being at 20% by 3pm (just an example) I'm at 40% ... for me that's a significant difference.
again, like I said before and what you failed to notice, is that I'll believe it when I see it, cause android has made similar claims before. a catchy name like Doze isn't enough to persuade me despite the favorable early test results.
if that extreme skepticism is over rating Doze I don't know what else to say!!
http://androidcommunity.com/android-ms-doze-feature-drastically-improves-battery-life-20150609/