HTC tells you why its better than SGS3

[biff6789]

No, just wrong. It doesn't just give you a "barely slightly bluer tone" It over saturates to an inexcusable extreme. Watching a dark movie is literally impossible, it turns the whole screen black. I've seen it myself. But here, see how much it over saturates and turns to black, even where there is no darkness at all.

[URL=http://img210.imageshack.us/img210/5986/gs3.png]Click to view quoted image
[/URL]


And it does effect the crispness and clarity. Quick lesson. HTC's LCD contains each each color inside every pixel, creating a crisp image. Amoled has each color spread out next to each other one color at a time in a pen tile matrix, creating a fuzzy image.

And on top of it all the GS3 screen is significantly dimmer. So feel free to buy an S3 but don't try to convince yourself or others that the screens are pretty much the same.

BTW, took a bus to vegas on monday with my buddy. and his phone lasted maybe 20 minutes longer than mine, both of us were watching movies the whole way. Now he did have the International, the U.S. version probably uses less power with it's snapdragon.

What's your problem, mate? You've been snapping back at anyone on this forum and others who dares mention anything pro S3, which you for some reason then take as a personal attack on your precious One X. It IS possible to have 2 really good phones on the market at the same time, ya know... Sensitive much?

Please try reading more carefully next time and you'll see that my comment was not about trashing the One X, nor did I ever state that they were even close to "the same" as you've falsely accused. Nice try, straw man. Also take note that I DID state that it "sucks" that the S3 uses PenTile (exact quote there, my friend). I've also mentioned in previous posts (that you've directly responded to, btw) that the One X's screen architecture is superior to that of the S3 and that I enjoy HTC products and intend to buy one in the future. Yet your first sentence out of the gate is that I'm "just wrong" and then you decide - falsely, btw - that I know nothing of the differences the two screen types and proceed to give me a "quick lesson" anyway.

All I was saying is that there is a silver lining in the fact that the S3 uses LED, which is proven in lab tests to use less energy in TVs, phones, and just about anything else that uses them. But instead of letting me offer any hope to people upset up this, you instead take it upon yourself to continue your crusade against any positive S3 comment by segueing my point, then arguing that CNET's lab tests must be incorrect because you've conducted a more scientific test on a bus or something. Relax bro, we're all friends here.

You're welcome to express your opinion here. Just please take note that you're starting to come off butthurt in all your posts.

 

[ScandaLeX]

Glad you asked that because I was wondering what the S3 did to him to piss him off so badly. My goodness....it's a phone that plenty of people will buy and like.

I've used HTC but not being interested in their latest offerings doesn't mean I'm going to hit as many forums as possible and trash it all to hell.

Tappin' from my SGP 5.0

 

[jroc]

Ahh screen tech debates, the infamous Pentile issue...lol Let me ask this question: at what distance does anyone really use their phone? I use mine at a distance that I can hold the phone in one hand and type on it with the other comfortably.

I had a G Nex, have a RAZR and Rezound. And looking at both phones right now...at....my normal viewing distance....I really cant tell one has Pentile and one doesnt. All 3 looked like they had the same screen res. Blueish tint, less whiter whites, less bright....yea I can see it...when next to my Rezound. On its own....its absolutely a non issue.

What I like about my RAZR screen over my Rezound...the blacks and contrast. Those 2 things make the Rezound look washed out. I can say with almost 90% certainty that most ppl looking at Netflix on both phones would prefer it on my RAZR. The one thing about LCD screens is it always looks like the contrast and brightness is cranked up too high. That gives it a washed out appearance next to an Amoled screen. So its either have a darker than normal screen...or have a washed out effect.

This is a few examples of real use scenarios I have come across on the net:
http://www.droid-life.com/2011/11/29/screen-comparison-galaxy-nexus-vs-droid-razr-vs-htc-rezound/

For the Droid Life one...look at it on your phone for an even better to real world use view. Still keep in mind its still magnified alot and its specific background colors. Looking at web pages on my RAZR...which most have a white background and isnt zoomed in as much...I cannot see any Pentile issues.

http://forums.androidcentral.com/sa...st-review-ive-watched-comparing-s3-one-x.html

This is one of the better screen comparisons I have seen. Some real world use scenarios. It shows where each screen does good and doesnt do good.

Specs are specs, nothing can change that...but in real world use situations....I really dont think its as bad as some make it. Me having a Rezound and RAZR, my eyes tell me this. I dont use my Rezound as much now....issues plus the screen just made it a disappointment overall. Honestly...IMHO...Pentile shows its ugly head...when held closer than normal. My normal viewing distance is about 1ft, 6 inches. If you can see it at that and beyond clearly vs a phone like the Rezound...I mean clearly and not searching, staring for Pentile..you have extremely good eye site.

 

[sublime187]

Samoled screens look like crap to me. It's not even about the Pentile. My Atrix was Pentile and it didn't have whites look ice blue. Whenever I see a galaxy phone, all I think is how disgusting that blue browser page looks.

But who really cares? It's just a phone. What's really funny is the people who don't own a HOX, or maybe they did but got rid of it, coming to the HOX forum to say that their future phone is going to be better than the HOX. Nobody should have to justify your purchase of electronic hardware. It's a PHONE. Take some time out of your day and get some fresh air, maybe touch a breast or a .

 

[crackberrytraitor]

What's your problem, mate? You've been snapping back at anyone on this forum and others who dares mention anything pro S3, which you for some reason then take as a personal attack on your precious One X. It IS possible to have 2 really good phones on the market at the same time, ya know... Sensitive much?

Please try reading more carefully next time and you'll see that my comment was not about trashing the One X, nor did I ever state that they were even close to "the same" as you've falsely accused. Nice try, straw man. Also take note that I DID state that it "sucks" that the S3 uses PenTile (exact quote there, my friend). I've also mentioned in previous posts (that you've directly responded to, btw) that the One X's screen architecture is superior to that of the S3 and that I enjoy HTC products and intend to buy one in the future. Yet your first sentence out of the gate is that I'm "just wrong" and then you decide - falsely, btw - that I know nothing of the differences the two screen types and proceed to give me a "quick lesson" anyway.

All I was saying is that there is a silver lining in the fact that the S3 uses LED, which is proven in lab tests to use less energy in TVs, phones, and just about anything else that uses them. But instead of letting me offer any hope to people upset up this, you instead take it upon yourself to continue your crusade against any positive S3 comment by segueing my point, then arguing that CNET's lab tests must be incorrect because you've conducted a more scientific test on a bus or something. Relax bro, we're all friends here.

You're welcome to express your opinion here. Just please take note that you're starting to come off butthurt in all your posts.

Sorry if I came off as overly hostile. FYI I was considering swapping my One X for a S3 as I'm still in my 30 days. I ended up pre-ordering an S3 off contract on friday so I can play with both phones, so I do think Samsung has merits.

What I do object to are what I consider legitimately disingenuous comments like saying the S3 only has a "barely slightly bluer tone" and going on to say it wouldn't effect clarity at such a high resolution. I don't consider that so much "giving upset people hope" so much as underplaying the truth to the verge of lying outright. Saying the S3 has a "barely slightly bluer tone" is like saying a Ford Taurus is barely slightly slower than a Ferrari.

People looking to buy a phone quite often spend time in the forums to gather information, and I am disinclined towards people putting out bad information as I too was looking for info to assist me in my decision.

And as to whether or not I trust Cnet, no, I haven't for years, they've had numerous occasions where large donations have effected their ratings. Android Central themselves said the One x and S3 perform almost equally well when they ran the phones through in identical intensive battery use test, the One X getting around 9 hours, the S3 getting about 9 and 1/2.

Again, sorry If I seemed nasty, or appeared to have it out for Samsung. I've barely posted on the S3 board, rather I spend most of my time in the One X section. Rest assured I probably won't be back until I get my S3

EDIT: Oh wait, this is in the One X section. Why are you lecturing me then? Why aren't you in the S3 board for goodness sakes? Especially you Scandalex, you said quite clearly that you aren't interested in HTC's offerings, and atm you roll a GII. Why would you be in a Samsung vs HTC comparison thread, on the One X board for any other reason than trying to assert your opinion about your phone of choice? You guys are kinda being hypocrites.

 

[jamdmyers]

I'm looking to upgrade soon, I'm on Vz so it maybe a few weeks before the X1 (yes Xone) becomes avail.
For those who consider the internal mem as a issue, you should watch the mobile nations where Jerry discusses the technical side of this, S3 has dedicated about 1 gig of internal mem to it's processors to allow for the multi tasking, which removes it from the 'users' pool.. so it's not a issue for me, Screen side I've seen many and prefer a more pure coloration.

Coming from a tbolt Battery isn't a issue either, I already deal with it and it rarely affects me, charger in car and 2 at home (1 up 1 down) no biggie there, and hey the X1 can replace the battery if it goes bad, u just have to open it up.

Storage wise I've always been curious why someone needs evey song on a phone, i mean every song or pic? I have a number of computers I am often xfering files back and forth to my phone, I set it up for trips etc.. I use dropbox as well but more for 'sharing' between devices than actual storage.

I also use ROMs and have good success with HTC and their community, they seem to be on top of required changes and streamline the overhead.

The only thing I'm hesitant on the X1 is the protruding lens.. any internationals have comments ? I'll use a screen protector but usually not a case.

 

[ab304945]

Exactly what's the process of using a 64 gig card with the One-X? That's
the only thing I think the GS3 has over the X the extra storage.

There is a dongle that you plug into the micro usb, and can use a sd card that way. Which is dumb in my opinion, alot of people will portion lose it


Sent from my LS670 using Android Central Forums

 

[biff6789]

Sorry if I came off as overly hostile...<snip>

I appreciate you clarifying the tone behind your remarks as it's often difficult to read someone's tone on internet boards. However, you then had to conclude your remarks with this little nugget:

EDIT: Oh wait, this is in the One X section. Why are you lecturing me then? Why aren't you in the S3 board for goodness sakes? Especially you Scandalex, you said quite clearly that you aren't interested in HTC's offerings, and atm you roll a GII. Why would you be in a Samsung vs HTC comparison thread, on the One X board for any other reason than trying to assert your opinion about your phone of choice? You guys are kinda being hypocrites.

The OP's exact point of this thread is a discussion about a comparison between the S3 and the One X, is it not? How then are any comments about just that - comparisons between the S3 and One X - irrelevant or trolling in nature? I could understand if this was a thread about the HOX radio and then some Samsung fanboi rolls in here and starts throwing out "LULZ, HOX radios suck. Sammy 4 life!!1!!1!" comments. But in a thread whose entire purpose is a discussion between the two phones, I see nothing improper as long as the discussion stays in those boundaries and no ad hominem attacks are made.

Again, WE LIKE BOTH PHONES! We are simply debating the semantics in the OP's original posted content. I don't understand why talking about that makes us "hypocrites".

 

[ab304945]

The GS3 also has USB OTG support.

So... While I still think your suggestion sound absolutely ridiculous, the One X is still a non-starter. I'm a big fan of multi-tasking (in the normal human sense, not in the technical sense) and there's no way I'm going to walk around with that P.O.S. hanging out of my phone when I can just put my SD Card (which I already own, and would cost nothing - zip - nada) into the other device and just use it. All I'd have to do it just put it in the phone before first boot and all my media is going to be there, with tons of space to spare on the card.

The GS3 seems like a No Compromise solution compared to the One X.

I think the Camera is fantastic on the One X, and it's why I'm scrounging this forum trying to find reasons to buy it since I have the cash literally sitting in front of me. But the storage issue is very real and a huge roadblock.

I hate TouchWiz and vowed to never buy a Samsung device again after the Vibrant [GPS, Update, Lag, etc. etc.] debacle, but I'm willing to be a complete hypocrite for that MicroSD slot.

Screens are a wash. PenTile is almost invisible at those densities. I've seen the Galaxy Nexus screen. It's really not a factor (the GS3 screen is better than the Nexus, even). If we were talking about something like the Droid Bionic then I'd agree, but it's simply not something I'm concerned with. Sound Quality, Storage Expandability, Battery Size, and Power/Data Plan Efficiency means more. Plus the GS3 technically multi-tasks better than the One X.

Been said many times. The gs3 camera is just as good as the 1x

Sent from my LS670 using Android Central Forums

 

[crackberrytraitor]

I appreciate you clarifying the tone behind your remarks as it's often difficult to read someone's tone on internet boards. However, you then had to conclude your remarks with this little nugget:



The OP's exact point of this thread is a discussion about a comparison between the S3 and the One X, is it not? How then are any comments about just that - comparisons between the S3 and One X - irrelevant or trolling in nature? I could understand if this was a thread about the HOX radio and then some Samsung fanboi rolls in here and starts throwing out "LULZ, HOX radios suck. Sammy 4 life!!1!!1!" comments. But in a thread whose entire purpose is a discussion between the two phones, I see nothing improper as long as the discussion stays in those boundaries and no ad hominem attacks are made.

Again, WE LIKE BOTH PHONES! We are simply debating the semantics in the OP's original posted content. I don't understand why talking about that makes us "hypocrites".

When there's an identical thread, with the same pictures and everything in the GS3 thread? Look it's quite simple. Generally if you're a GS3 fan posting pro GS3 rhetoric in a One X board you're a troll. If you want to do that there's an S3 board just for that purpose. The same goes for One X fans trying to assert themselves on the Sammy board. Trying to press your opinion about your phone of choice on someone who obviously has another one is just trolling.

And as we agree this is a discussion, I will simply say I was responding attentively to what I consider a disingenuous comment, and was then quite amused to read a long and angry reply detailing me in why I was wrong and butthurt, because I didn't agree with you, lol.


Sent from my HTC One X using Android Central Forums

 

[biff6789]

You mean like calling someone "straw man"...

LOL, a straw man is not name calling, it's a logical fallacy of argument; one that you committed. Look it up.

It's beyond clear that everything I say goes completely over your head. That's three strikes for you, my friend. I'm done.

 

[crackberrytraitor]

LOL, a straw man is not name calling, it's a logical fallacy of argument; one that you committed. Look it up.

It's beyond clear that everything I say goes completely over your head. That's three strikes for you, my friend. I'm done.

Lol, my colleague was reading over my shoulder and laughed at me for having gone 34 years without having heard the term "straw man argument". I do however understand the meaning of a logical fallacy, quite well enough to understand that it doesn't apply in in this usage.

So whoosh, over my head but it doesn't effect the validity of either of our points of view in this discussion.

I say good day.

Sent from my HTC One X using Android Central Forums

 

[rfutty]

I love HTC but I didn't get the HTC one only because no removable battery or sdcard slot. But I guess according to HTC that's better then having both. Idk. Far as screen goes I couldn't care less. However my sensation has a better battery life. I've been off the charger maybe 20mins after it being 100% its at 86% and all I'm doing is browsing the web

 

[jj2339]

When there's an identical thread, with the same pictures and everything in the GS3 thread? Look it's quite simple. Generally if you're a GS3 fan posting pro GS3 rhetoric in a One X board you're a troll. If you want to do that there's an S3 board just for that purpose. The same goes for One X fans trying to assert themselves on the Sammy board. Trying to press your opinion about your phone of choice on someone who obviously has another one is just trolling.

Sent from my HTC One X using Android Central Forums

Wow, that's a very restrictive way to look at it. So then anyone who wants a 'fair' comparison better post two threads, one in each forum, to try and get an answer? Cause by your logic, if you post in a HOX board, you can only hear "HOX IS THE BEST" and if you post in an S3 board, you only hear "S3 rules!". So how exactly is anyone going to get a reasonable argument? Is that not what the OP is trying to get? I don't remember reading "OMG, only post positive things about HOX, since that's the only thing I want to hear about".

Your definition of trolling is not what trolling is. Trolling is coming in and attacking others for having a view and being nasty. I'd say the person you are calling a troll has been anything BUT a troll. However, I do agree with you that that there HAS been trollish behavior in this thread.

 

[ItsaRaid]

I thought this is a place to seek help, not insults and brick throwing. At the end of the day these are phones..that's all they are- This forum should not be a place for "Bullies" to thrive.

 

[wilfreb]

Those papers are nonesense and without any backup.

Read this and see for yourself that the GS3 is the best overall

m.gsmarena.com/quad_core_shootout-review-790.php

 

[crackberrytraitor]

Those papers are nonesense and without any backup.

Read this and see for yourself that the GS3 is the best overall

m.gsmarena.com/quad_core_shootout-review-790.php

Yes, because GSM area prefers it, it must be the best. I can link reviews from other major sites who prefer the One X. And the quad core comparison does not effect any devices sold in the U.S. since all the flagship phones use the same CPU.

Sent from my Nexus 7 using Android Central Forums

 

[icebike]

Jj2339

You need to look up what trolling is.
It is posting unpopular view points or topics with the intention of provoking a hue and cry of responses.

Name calling and personal attacks are not trolling.

Try here http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Troll_(Internet)


Sent from my HOX

 

[crackberrytraitor]

Wow, that's a very restrictive way to look at it. So then anyone who wants a 'fair' comparison better post two threads, one in each forum, to try and get an answer? Cause by your logic, if you post in a HOX board, you can only hear "HOX IS THE BEST" and if you post in an S3 board, you only hear "S3 rules!". So how exactly is anyone going to get a reasonable argument? Is that not what the OP is trying to get? I don't remember reading "OMG, only post positive things about HOX, since that's the only thing I want to hear about".

Your definition of trolling is not what trolling is. Trolling is coming in and attacking others for having a view and being nasty. I'd say the person you are calling a troll has been anything BUT a troll. However, I do agree with you that that there HAS been trollish behavior in this thread.

If you wanted a balanced discussion you would post something like "HTC One X vs GS3 comparison discussion." You wouldn't post fake inflammatory documents with an equally inflammatory thread title. I think YOU need to look up the definition of trolling.

Sent from my Nexus 7 using Android Central Forums

 

[LegalAmerican]

I don't have a dog in this fight, but i think both phones are awesome. I do think I'd get the S3 though simply cause I generally prefer the look of Touchwiz over Sense.

Sent from my DROID RAZR using Android Central Forums