Do you know if the seller might have flashed a different firmware on the phone to make it compatible with AT&T? If the phone is updating with a firmware that's not intended for the exact variant, there's always a chance that something won't work right. It's probably impossible to check right now, but one way to determine this is to see if the model number in the Settings>About Phone menu (or embedded in the firmware designation) differs slightly from the model number on the box.