The simple fact is, anyone excusing this POS FPS is a true fanboi in denial. Anyone who's used a true FPS that works well and fast, knows what's possible--and has expectations.
To dismiss this as "you're doing it wrong" is insanity at its highest level. If I wasn't doing it wrong before on my S9+, and it worked at various angles and parts of the finger AND it was extremely fast (virtually instant), then that's the bar to meet or exceed. If the current FPS isn't working, it's because Samsung ignored that bar and built a POS that they could technically call a FPS for the purposes of marketing and putting on their sales collaterals and checklists against the competition.
I can get it to work--but after all the time and effort I generally have to put into it, I might as well just use a PIN code. And that's just unlocking the screen. With regard to Samsung Pay, I am batting ZERO on getting the FPS to work. I ALWAYS have to put in the PIN code.
Funny how it was 100%, including Samsung Pay, on my S9+ and yet this thing can barely work to unlock the screen, and can't work AT ALL to unlock Pay.
"You're doing it wrong." Yeah, right. That's what I say to Samsung--you did it wrong. If it's not functional to the level of your previous S9, and at the level of the competition, you did it COMPLETELY wrong.
And it's even worse if the competition did an in-screen one better. But the simple point is, they should have had the guts to avoid the in-screen unit and put it on the power switch as well, just like with the 10e. Or maybe put it both places. I can only imagine how some of those meetings went between engineering and marketing. I've been in just that type of meeting--and I know how some of those marketing people can be. Reality doesn't exist for them.